I'd be interested to see if you asked them what they thought each players career highs in the various stats would be, where they came down? I mean I can't imagine they both don't have Okafor in the 25/12 range for points and rebounds if not higher and yet that somehow equates to 10th most potential. I mean either this is the best draft in history, or those guys are just being overly critical with Okafor. I imagine it is latter.
I can't imagine either having Okafor peaking at 25 PPG and 12 RPG. There's no one in the NBA doing that this year. More to the point, out of 78 centers listed in Basketball-Reference.com Okafor ranks as follows through yesterday:
65th Total Shooting % (17th percentile)
40th PER (49th percentile)
68th Defensive Box +/- (13th percentile)
53rd Total Rebounding % (32nd percentile)
Out of the top 30 centers in MPG, he's 29th in Total Shooting % ahead only of Noah who doesn't play under the basket and after Drummond. He's 24th in Total Rebounding % after Brook Lopez. He's 29th in Defensive Box +/- ahead of only Kantar, and he's 24th in PER between Len and Noah.
IOW, he's playing poorly despite putting up numbers on a very bad team. I thought he was over-rated based off his play in the tourney and his defensive deficiencies/ slow reaction time, but I'm shocked about how bad his stats are as opposed to the eye test, which is why you use both. He'll get better, but he's no savior.