In this case you're asking me to defend arguments I'm not making while ignoring what I am actually saying. Forgive me if I don't indulge you.
Being the most upvoted comment on reddit has no bearing on the legitimacy of the idea -- particularly because if it is something a majority of sports fans believe to be true, it is almost certainly less correct than they collectively assume: if only because their access to information is entirely at the "civilian"/spectator level.