Even that first video with him "setting a pick" and rolling to the basket doesn't exactly instill confidence . . . he just doesn't look very coordinated or decisive in his movements.
Maybe he can turn out to be one of those guys who looks uncoordinated but is actually effective in the same way that Paul Pierce looks slow but is deceptively quick.
TP. He's working hard, or so it seems, so he'll improve. How much? We don't know, only can hope, but he's doing what's needed.
As an Optimist Prime (credit goes to Fair/Foulweatherfan for the Optimist Prime/Negatron dicotomy), I see him becoming a useful player in a couple of years. And I understand the CelticsBlog Negatrons have a point when they say Melo will never be an NBA player, but what's the point in stating it in every thread about him, even when the thread is about him putting in the work to improve?
As a TA fan, I've read "Bad Tony" threads ad nauseam in CelticsBlog, and then, when Ainge didn't offer him a bigger role (which was the right decision at the time, IMO) and he went to find his place in Memphis, people started calling DA out and praising TA as an All NBA defender. I'm not comparing TA to Fab, but I think we should cut some slack to Celtic players, and allow them to improve before we label them as "useless". When Troy Murphy was the genius deadline signing, I hated to see Erden and Gody walk to make room for him, but even then I tried to find good things about Troy. And given the huge amounts of love some guys like Shav or Steamer get around here, I think Fab Melo deserves his time to develop. /rant