Dirk came to prominence by destroying everyone in sight at the Nike Hoop Summit at 18yrs old...
Abroad, Nowitzki's progress was noticed. In 1996, FC Barcelona Bàsquet wanted to sign him, but Nowitzki refused to move before finishing his Abitur.[18] A year later, the teenager participated in the Nike "Hoop Heroes Tour," where he played against NBA stars like Charles Barkley and Scottie Pippen. In a 30-minute show match, Nowitzki outplayed Barkley and even dunked on him, causing the latter to exclaim: "The boy is a genius. If he wants to enter the NBA, he can call me."[19] On March 29, 1998, Nowitzki was chosen to play in the Nike Hoop Summit, one of the premier talent watches in U.S. men's basketball. In a match between the U.S. talents and the international talents, Nowitzki scored 33 points on 6-of-12 shooting, 14 rebounds and 3 steals for the internationals[3] and outplayed future US NBA stars Rashard Lewis and Al Harrington. He impressed with a combination of quickness, ball handling, and shooting range, and from that moment a multitude of European and NBA clubs wanted to recruit him.[20]
You can NOT compare KO to a HOFer... this is completely ridiculous
You might want to check out this link here:
http://galleries.nba.com/gallery/summerleague-past-stars/slideshow/Kevin_Durant/08IL625aYg6XmI actually found this pretty interesting because some of these future stars didn't really dominate so much during summer league. Some of the notes were as follows:
Lebron - 15.8 points, 7.3 rebounds, 4.3 assists. Very nice stats but not uber-elite as you'd expect
Carmello - barely played and stats were not not even worthy of note
Dwight - struggled at points due to lack of strength (wow?!?!)
Chris Paul - struggled initially due to injured wrist
D Wade - Avceraged only 13.4 PPG
Deron Williams - Played well, but not exceptionally so
James Harden - Averaged 15 PPG and 3 RPG
Zach Randolf - Barely played, stats were not noteworthy
The reason the above interests me is that everybody here has been suggesting that unless a player absolutely dominates against summer league competition, it's unlikely he has NBA potential (let alone superstar potential). I don't think this is accurate because if you look at the above examples, none of them (Statistically) really hint at what those guys would eventually become.
The best statistical line there is Lebron's, but that guy is putting up something like 27/7/7 consistently against NBA competition, so a summer league showing of 16/7/4 is hardly representative of how dominant he'd eventually be. I would have expected something like 35/10/6 from a guy with his "GOAT" level of talent.
Wade averaged only 13 PPG - nothing spectacular at all and in no way a hint at what woudl become one of the greatest scorers in the NBA for years. DItto HArden's 15 per game which seems pretty average against Summer League competition...considering he averaged 26 PPG last season.
So looking at a guy like Olynyk who is seriously dominating summer league so far (averaging something like 19/7/3) things are looking pretty good. People bring up the strength issue but Dwight was listed as struggling due to lack of strength, and he's a walking tank these days.
By no means an assurance that KO will dominate in the future league, but by no means a sign that he can't either. I honestly don't see any real skill that Dirk has that KO doesn't. Good jumper? check. Post scoring ability? Check. Good hands? Check. PAssing skills? Check. High IQ? Check. Agile for a 7 footer? Check. Average strength, defense and rebounding? Check. He may never get there, but who knows? If he can translate into even 70% of what Dirk was in his prime I'd be pretty content. I see him being a 15 / 7 / 2 guy at the absolute minimum with high scoring efficiency to go with it.