If I had to pick the lesser of 2 evils, I would rather have KG back than Pierce but I would almost cry to see Pierce go and play for another team. It just feels wrong on every level but at the same time, I think Pierce is kinda "acting" like he is gone. When he said he would be willing to come back for a 1 day contract and retire a Celtic, that to me sounds like you've made up your mind that you are not opposed to playing elsewhere.
Naturally, I want to keep both KG AND Pierce. And KG is appearing to make it seem like Pierce coming back is BIG with him. In some ways it almost feels like posturing by the Big 2 in the wake of how things went down with Ray last year. It almost seems like Pierce needs to see that he is wanted to a degree that was much better than Ray was shown last year or he wants out, just like Ray did.
Unfortunately, I think Pierce needs to either accept a lot more coming off the bench time or he needs to come back in exceptional condition. I don't know why, but it always looks like Pierce is just "slightly" pudgy and not in as great shape as he *could* be in. He plays good/great one game and then the next his shots look flat as a pancake and he can't make jack and he's a step slow just like what happened in Game 6. This seems to be happening more and more often and I think age has caught him and he just isn't conditioned as well as he could be or should be to give it 100% night after night like someone of a similar age like Kobe does before he got hurt.
I almost feel like this offseason is a game of chicken. KG goes if Pierce goes. Pierce is ready to walk on the Celtics, may need to be wanted and both players probably want a better supporting cast if they stay. If I could keep 1 and let the other walk, I'd keep KG and let Pierce go. But it feels like an all or nothing situation brewing. I'm hoping KG is enough for Pierce to stay knowing Rondo will be back along with hopefully a better lineup to compete. But I'm not expecting Pierce to be any better than he was this year and unless he takes fewer minutes and comes off the bench a lot more, I'm not so sure we should fight real hard to keep him and that alone makes me really sad because I love Pierce, I just don't think he can bring it night after night anymore. And Pierce not coming back could certainly cause KG not to come back.
Is this a for real scenario or a game of chicken waiting to see if someone calls their bluff or caves?
I'm not sure I want to find out.