I am amazed that there are people that think Martin is at all an effective replacement for Harden.
Last season, Martin shot 41.3% from the field.
Harden shot 49.1%.
Martin is going to play approximately the same role as Harden, which means he will get the same number of minutes and touches. Since he is a whopping 8 percentage points less efficient a scorer, he will produce less by default.
Seriously, do you people not understand how basketball works? You can't say that K-Mart averaged 23 points a game and just plug that production onto the Thunder. Scoring is about how many points you get per unit playing time, which relies on shooting a higher percentage.
Aside from the fact that Martin had a lower than usual fg% because of a shoulder injury that affected his play, the way basketball works is that Martin was the #1 offensive option in Houston, so a) he commanded a lot of attention from the defense and b) he had to force up a lot of shots when the offense broke down. Now he'll generally be the 2nd or 3rd option, command less attention from the defense, and force up fewer shots when the offense breaks down, so it's likely that his fg% will be higher than it's been in the past. Just like how PP and Ray both took fewer shots and made a higher percentage of them when they were put on the same team.
good points above. just to add to the discussion...
offensively, both players are very good, though i agree harden may be seen the better of the two when we consider their ages. harden could be growing better, martin could be facing a decline. however, this does not mean that marting is a slug offensively. not at all.
the real significant differences i see are...
1. harden is by far a better defender than martin. martin is know as a weak defender so OKC will have to figure out a way to coverup this loss somehow.
2. martin has a history of injuries. in the past 6 years he has played in:
61 games
51 games
22 games
24 games
80 games
40 games
in only 1 out of the last 6 years has he played close to a full season. not good.
but having said all that, martin's role was to produce much of the scoring in houston and carry the team offensively. in OKC, not so much will be expected of him. Durant and westbrook will make sure of that. maybe martin's health will hold up when he doesnt have to produce so many points and defenses dont focus as much on him. he may also increase he efficiency. we will have to see about that.
also, it is likely that the charlotte draft pick will be in the 4-6 range next year. this may allow OKC to pick up a great young player who compliments durant and westbrook. a number of good power forwards should be available. so, martin maybe more of a bridge than a permanent fixture.
in any case, this is a really bold move by OKC and houston. i am really curious as to how it works out.