Who is your top 23(Updating)

[Mr October]

on what planet is 31 year old d-wade, shooting 10% from 3,  better than dwight howard?

The one where Wade just got another ring and Howard is coming off major back surgery and in a new system?

I'd expect Howard to pass Wade soon, I just don't think he's there yet.

Howard can carry a team of junk to 55 wins. Wade with a team of junk is more like 45 wins. I'll take the extra wins. Size matters that much in the NBA. The Lakers could be very, very scary if they get the chemistry right.

[Who]

So is Tyson Chandler now the most overrated "star" in the NBA?

In a heartbeat I'd take M Gasol, Duncan and Horford as bigs over him. What makes Chandler so much better than say Joakim Noah?

I would say Tyson Chandler is more like a top 40 level player.

[billysan]

Lots of folks still underestimate Paul Pierce and Manu Ginobili.

If 90-100% healthy they are top 15. Sadly they are often damaged (Pierce often more effective handling the injuries) by the time the playoffs roll around. That makes me confidently rank them in the 20s.

I think I understand your point but IMO the OP was referring to all the listed players being at 100%. Also some folks were leaving them off the lists period.