I think the thing to take out of last nights game is that the C's are still better than the Knicks we just need our Captain. The Celtics had no one who could go after Anthony's shaky defense, which causes him to be less effective on offense. Carmelo is definitely better than Pierce by far, but he shouldn't be scoring 37 points in 34 minutes, ever.
A quick look at Anthony's plus/minus from the playoffs and last night shows how important Pierce is for Cs to beat the Knicks. Last year in the playoffs Anthony had a -40 over the 4 playoff games. In last nights game Anthony was +15. The Celtics had the biggest runs in the 3rd when Anthony was on the bench with foul trouble.
If you want to see how these teams match up look at the 3rd quarter with both Pierce and Carmelo not in the game. The Celtics outscored them by 18 points. I don't think anyone should panic, we just need our Captain back. The Knicks might have closed the gap but they are still not better.