I think Cleveland and the Suns are pretty comparable. Both have good roleplaying bigs and a pile of crap other than that.
I think Detroit and Charlotte are probably worse off though. At least the Cavs/Suns are going to get lottery picks. The Bobcats or Pistons might end up in the playoffs!
I think the outlook for Detroit improved a bit recently, partly because MacGrady has started playing well. If he stays healthy that's a nice addition. They also need Jerebko to come back fully healthy and Daye to turn out good. I think Monroe will be a good player. IMO they could get something really nice by using Stuckey to trade Rip Hamilton (trade both). Get a real PG to pair with McGrady.....Their pick this year might not be lottery but it might not be horrible...I'd rather be Detroit than Charlotte, by a large margin.
How does McGrady playing slightly replacement level PG/SF help their future?
I mean he's not getting his legs back, the only reason their current line up has worked to get them to .400 basketball is that they have a size advantage with Stuckey/McGrady/Prince. Trade away stuckey and that advantage is gone.
I can't do a great evaluation of McGrady...just going by his past ability, current stats and acceptance of being a facilitator above all else, and assuming he's having a healthy run and could therefore improve even more. But I don't know his true value at the moment nor his true level of physical health (recovery)...if it's as you say then cancel him out of the bright future part.....
But I just think they have some talent to keep or trade, more than Cleveland or Charlotte. They could demand a lot for Stuckey and Rip, and if they don't get enough then keep them. If they want to keep Stuckey they could trade Gordon and Rip instead. I think they have enough assets to trade for one really good player, so they would have: 1 really good player, McGrady, Prince, Monroe, Jerebko and Gordon or Stuckey. Sign the right free agent or agents and it doesn't seem so bad to me....Or, I think they have enough talent that if they wanted to do a complete rebuild they could do a lot of trading and really suck for a couple years but also have some really nice assets from those trades.....