Yeah, good point FaFnir, this could be way too early. But I've been watching ball a long time. I think Durant is unique.
I also agree that some of the guys on the list, like Jordan and Bird had reps of being hard on teammates. But there's a difference to me between being a hard ass and donkey's ass.
Bird, Jordan, KG - hard assess.
Kobe, LeBron, Isaiah - donkey's assess.
And I don't put Kobe in this class because he's a Laker...he's proven time and again he's a preening self focused donkey's ass. As did/have Isaiah and LeBron with alot of their antics.
Dwayne Wade, he's solid but I don't think he's at these other guy's levels where he makes everyone around him better. He's just a great solo performer to me.
The truly great ones have an intangible ability to make other guys around them better because they're willing to share it all, it's not just about the spot light being on them, to them.
I can't put Kobe anywhere near Jordan, Bird or Magic. It's not just about rings to me.
It's an intangible quality. I think Durant has it, it's who he is. Same for Duncan, Garnett, Bird, Jordan, Magic, etc...
Some of these guys found the right situations early and they won rings, alot of them. Others, like KG didn't find it but they were always the same player, every night, without fail. Stockton and malone had it, even without the rings
It's about the game to these guys, it's never about them. It's about winning and bringing your teammates with you - as Russell said to KG when he arrived in Boston. He told KG he would get a ring, but he'd probably have to wrap his arms around the rest of the guys and carry them with him.
What Russell was saying was that Ray and paul were great, hall of fame players but they werent' KG. There is a difference. It just is what it is.
Anyway, to me, Durant has it all. I would fear a Durant lead team to a LeBron lead team of equal talent by a margin of about 3-1. Because for Durant the game isn't about him, it's about how he can win the game. That's all those guys are focused on and that's what makes the difference say, a Magic or Bird and a Kobe or a LeBron.
And I don't have alot of information about all these guys, but if you've watched bball long enough, you can tell who's who byt thw way they carry themselves and how they go about their business.
Durant is the Real Deal. The others are pretenders.
IMHO