The first talent tier was five guys this year, not 12-14 guys like in years past
LeBron, Durant, Wade, Howard, Kobe.
After that there were probably about 15-18 guys that were in the next tier level
You think Tim Duncan and Chris Paul are on the same tier as Brook Lopez, Rajon Rondo, and Danny Granger?
I couldn't disagree more. They're all good players, but the first two are much better. (Presumably, that's why you tried to move up to #6, rather than, say, #18.)
Uh uh uh. Don't put names coming out of my mouth that I didn't say. I said there were 15-18 guys. I didn't sat it was the guys that were the next 15-18 guys picked. People made mistakes thereafter. That doesn't mean they would have belonged on my list where they got drafted
I'd be curious to know your top-23, if you had five elite guys, and then essentially 15-18 guys with roughly the same value (especially if I'm reading your comment right that Lopez, Rondo, and Granger weren't necessarily in that top 23).
I'll accept that you're not in love with CP3 or Deron, since you're not a big fan of point guards. However, surely you'd have Duncan and Carmelo rated much, much more highly than guys getting picked in the 15 - 20 range, correct?
Higher, yes. But only within the same talent tier bracket which I think takes a definitive dip thereafter.
Players I had in that area:
Duncan
Williams
Nowitzki
Bosh
Paul
Anthony
P. Gasol
Roy
Johnson
Stoudemire
Pierce
Bynum
Rondo
Boozer
Smith
That was my next group of 15 talent tier. I think each is a definite step below the first five. But for different reasons I think each can be a number 1 guy on a team. Do I believe that every guy in that group is of equal talent? Hell no, just the same way I don't feel LeBron and Kobe are on equal talent. But are they all within a relative talent tier. Yes, I believe so and I believe for that reason that there isn't a whole lot of talent difference between pick number 6 and pick 20.
I've had a very civil discussion with Fafnir about this. You and he see things differently than a large group of the GMs do. Ask those guys with picks in the top 15 in the first round how hard it was to deal picks. It's been a different game this year to start off with than past years. My guess is if the same core group of owners are around next year, trading those picks will become even more difficult.