The original poster seems to know precious little about Bosh. Bosh is an excellent player. He's not a 5, but that's hardly a knock against him unless it's also a knock on Garnett.
Also, Bosh was better than KG last year.
Not better Defensively.
Bosh is a great player, no doubt - top 15. But the shame of it all is that he is not intimidating defensively.
He pulled down 10.8 boards in TOR - with Rasho Nesterovic and Bargnani as his help?
To me, of course he would pull down that amount of boards - with no true center to contend for the rebounds.
No, KG is a better defensive player but it's hard to assess Bosh, given the awful defensive players around him. Toronto played terrible perimeter D and their other bigs were largely useless defensively, particularly on help D. Bosh ended up having to do too much to make up for defensive lapses in other places. He remains an okay one on one defender.
Bosh is a better rebounder than KG now. You can spin the numbers however you like but it's true.
Well....I just can't see where Bosh was an even ok one-on-one defender. The funny thing is that according to ESPN player profiles, Bargnani blocked more shots than Bosh.
You are right, though - stats are hard to assess a lot of times, but I just don't get the same feeling about Bosh in MIA as say if it was KG (even at 34 yrs of age) in MIA vice Bosh.
Weird way of looking at it, but to me the Defensive mindset that KG brings is invaluable.
Wade-Lebron-KG = Title 2 for MIA. Wade-Lebron-Bosh? Not sure.
Can Bosh do a better job on Gasol than KG? Not sure..can't see it. Bosh VS Josh Smith? Rashard Lewis? Boozer?
To me, the Defensive Presence is key. Even in the LA series, Gasol did in fact prove to me that he was the real deal - but even with that admission - Gasol absolutely disappeared in Boston - due to KG.
I can see KG lessening Bosh's impact, too.