I say yes, simply because the class of 2012 doesn't look to be especially strong. If it's Paul or some borderline star, you take Paul every time and worry about positions later.
The fact of the matter is that we while we can say "neither plays well at the 2" we don't know how the two of them would play together.
Sign him, try it out, and then trade one of them if it doesn't work.
Don't see it happening though.