Who is the 2nd best QB of the last generation of QBs?

[Eja117]

Now that the Brady vs Manning thing has been settled the question is who is #2?

I gotta go with Kurt Warner.

I guess I'm considering this since the first Rams championship.

[Eja117]

I guess you could make an argument for Rothlisberger, but I see Warner as the one with the better resume despite the injuries and seasons of mediocrity

[Finkelskyhook]

Now that the Brady vs Manning thing has been settled the question is who is #2?

I gotta go with Kurt Warner.

I guess I'm considering this since the first Rams championship.

I didn't realize it had been settled.

[Roy Hobbs]

I'd still take Manning over Brady.  Brady would be #2, Warner #3 (although he has an odd career), and Rothlisberger #4. 

I left Favre out of my evaluation, simply because his latter career has overall been distinguishable from his earlier, greater years.

[Eja117]

Now that the Brady vs Manning thing has been settled the question is who is #2?

I gotta go with Kurt Warner.

I guess I'm considering this since the first Rams championship.

I didn't realize it had been settled.

You didn't?

[Eja117]

I'd still take Manning over Brady.  Brady would be #2, Warner #3 (although he has an odd career), and Rothlisberger #4. 

I left Favre out of my evaluation, simply because his latter career has overall been distinguishable from his earlier, greater years.

The only thing Manning did better than Brady was make better commercials.

He threw for more yards in a video gamish sort of way, but that's it. That's all he's got. I think he might have an extra MVP award.

Brady did more with less and isn't personally responsible for any Super Bowl losses like Manning.

More rings against better opponents and his SB loss was in the last minute and half, which took a miracle play and he wasn't personally responsible for it.

Also played with virtually no Pro Bowlers on offense till after his rings, unlike Manning who had HOFers

The only advantage Brady had was Adam V

[Donoghus]

The debate hasn't been settled.

It's Brady or Manning but it's not over.