What you fail to point out is that Martin, for all practical purposes, missed the whole season the previous year, and he was, any Nuggests fan can tell you, largely ineffective in the 07-08 season, no matter what the stats tell you. Moreover, as was already said, Nene was not the same player; and, for that matter, neither was JR Smith.
I think Chauncey Billups deserves a lot of credit for JR Smith's improvement. He's been an excellent big brother figure for him both on and off the court. Helping him handle himself better off the court, practice habits, work ethic, and a better understanding of how to play. Iverson, reportedly, had the opposite effect.
I agree, one can't include Nene on that playoff roster. He wasn't healthy. Nowhere close to being healthy. What did he play? 20-50 ineffectual minutes? (30 minutes, looked it up) After a season of sitting out with cancer (cancer?)? C'mon, Nene can't be included as part of that team.
Kenyon Martin wasn't as good in 2007-08 as he was last season but he was still most of the ways there.
Also, if you don't consider Marcus Camby a better player and contributor than Nene, then throws that argument out the window and I don't know if we can discuss this further.
I gotta disagree here. I don't think Camby comes close to Nene's abilities defensively or offensively.
I think Nene is a vastly superior all-round man-to-man defender, particularly in the low post, a vastly superior pick and roll defender, and a generally superior team defender. Camby gets a few more weakside blocks.
Camby is a better rebounder but not by much because Nene actually puts a body on someone and keeps the opponent off the glass, unlike Camby who gets big rebounding numbers but also gives up big rebounding numbers to opponents. Look at the team rebounding numbers for this -- Camby's Nuggets got beat on the backboards overall (100 boards over a season) + while he was on the floor (48.8% on vs 48.5% off). Nene's Nuggets out-rebounded their opponent overall (30 boards over the season) + when he was on the floor (50.5% on vs 48.5% off).
Offensively, Nene has a much better jump shot, sets better screens and is a lot more effective in pick and roll situations, has better hands, is more efficient (TS% of 60=% his last three healthy years) and is a better finisher around the rim. He also runs the floor better than Camby does.
I think Nene is a vastly superior player to Marcus Camby.