The Ultimate Draft - Congrats Edgar: Team Voted Best Overall

[Redz]

I will join.

Excellent Evantime.

I think when the voting hits 20 I'm going to lock it.  After we've established the categories, we'll then make a list of participants, and discuss what criteria the teams will be judged on.

[Evantime34]

Now is it supposed to be the best available you can get at any given time. Or are you putting together a cohesive team that would be able to do challenges similar to on reality shows?

[Redz]

Now is it supposed to be the best available you can get at any given time. Or are you putting together a cohesive team that would be able to do challenges similar to on reality shows?

We shall discuss this.

A couple of ideas I had for traits to pursue for the teams:

A basketball team
A battle with specific weapons
A debate
A beauty pageant
Starting a business
 
I don't know, we could do anything.  But choosing scientists and world leaders etc...based on their merits as basketball players intrigues me.

We can toss around some more ideas, then vote on that facet as well.

[fairweatherfan]

I'm down - let me know when you flesh the idea out a little.

[Roy Hobbs]

Now is it supposed to be the best available you can get at any given time. Or are you putting together a cohesive team that would be able to do challenges similar to on reality shows?

We shall discuss this.

A couple of ideas I had for traits to pursue for the teams:

A basketball team
A battle with specific weapons
A debate
A beauty pageant
Starting a business
 
I don't know, we could do anything.  But choosing scientists and world leaders etc...based on their merits as basketball players intrigues me.

We can toss around some more ideas, then vote on that facet as well.

I say, keep it *completely* subjective.  Teams will be judged however opposing GMs want them to be judged.  Thus, making it much more difficult to put a "worth" on an individual draft pick.

[Redz]

Now is it supposed to be the best available you can get at any given time. Or are you putting together a cohesive team that would be able to do challenges similar to on reality shows?

We shall discuss this.

A couple of ideas I had for traits to pursue for the teams:

A basketball team
A battle with specific weapons
A debate
A beauty pageant
Starting a business
 
I don't know, we could do anything.  But choosing scientists and world leaders etc...based on their merits as basketball players intrigues me.

We can toss around some more ideas, then vote on that facet as well.

I say, keep it *completely* subjective.  Teams will be judged however opposing GMs want them to be judged.  Thus, making it much more difficult to put a "worth" on an individual draft pick.

that works too 

[Redz]

bumping this...there are 5 more spots

[Redz]

One more bump, then we'll move on to the next step.

[Redz]

List of those who have stated interest in doing this.

If you would like to be added (or taken off) the list let me know.

17 people:

Redz
Kwhit10
celticinorlando
cdif911
IndeedProceed
Hoyo de Monterrey
Gainesville Celtic
Gomesfan
Roy Hobbs
wdleehi
JamItMaurice
Evantime34
Celtic Fan Forever
fairweatherfan
KCattheStripe
Casperian
SSFan
Edgar* - I'm demanding his presence though he has not volunteered    (if you insist otherwise I will relent Edgar)

[KCattheStripe]

Any way I can get in?

[Redz]

Any way I can get in?

Just like that.  You're in.

Capping it at 20.  Did you vote?

[Gainesville Celtic]

Now is it supposed to be the best available you can get at any given time. Or are you putting together a cohesive team that would be able to do challenges similar to on reality shows?

We shall discuss this.

A couple of ideas I had for traits to pursue for the teams:

A basketball team
A battle with specific weapons
A debate
A beauty pageant
Starting a business
 
I don't know, we could do anything.  But choosing scientists and world leaders etc...based on their merits as basketball players intrigues me.

We can toss around some more ideas, then vote on that facet as well.

I say, keep it *completely* subjective.  Teams will be judged however opposing GMs want them to be judged.  Thus, making it much more difficult to put a "worth" on an individual draft pick.

Totally wide open could be fun --- but making a Basketball team would give it a little context to here at Cblog i think ..... and really it woudl still be COMPLETELY SUBJECTIVE since we know little/nothing of C3PO's shot or Pavarotti's post game

[Hoyo de Monterrey]

Ask Dark Lord if it's easy to box out R2D2

[Redz]

Now is it supposed to be the best available you can get at any given time. Or are you putting together a cohesive team that would be able to do challenges similar to on reality shows?

We shall discuss this.

A couple of ideas I had for traits to pursue for the teams:

A basketball team
A battle with specific weapons
A debate
A beauty pageant
Starting a business
 
I don't know, we could do anything.  But choosing scientists and world leaders etc...based on their merits as basketball players intrigues me.

We can toss around some more ideas, then vote on that facet as well.

I say, keep it *completely* subjective.  Teams will be judged however opposing GMs want them to be judged.  Thus, making it much more difficult to put a "worth" on an individual draft pick.

Totally wide open could be fun --- but making a Basketball team would give it a little context to here at Cblog i think ..... and really it woudl still be COMPLETELY SUBJECTIVE since we know little/nothing of C3PO's shot or Pavarotti's post game

Well, here's the thing.  If we enjoy it one way, we could always do it again with a different set of criteria to choose by.

If it sucks, then it sucks!

I'm open to whatever. We can do a vote on how to do things I suppose.

[Gainesville Celtic]

Ask Dark Lord if it's easy to box out R2D2

this could get good