Cookies or Ice Cream

[SSFan V]

In honor of Redz "Apples or Oranges" post, I offer you:

Cookies or Ice Cream*

Which is better?


*Ice cream based on cookies such as Oreo or Cookie Dough or even a Chipwich counts as Ice Cream.

[SSFan V]

Ice Cream wins this by a huge margin.

[RAcker]

Actually I go with Cookies if these are stand alone items.  Ice Cream is more versatile though when in combination with other things (milk shakes, etc.).

[Redz]

This would require some specifics under what flavor etc...In fact I really love combining the two.

I guess I'd go with ice cream if you told me you were going to take one away from me.

[wdleehi]

I am a sucker for a fresh baked, a little doughy, chocolate chip cookie.

[indeedproceed]

Ice Cream, its not even close. Not even remotely close.

[EatSleepBreatheGreen]

I am a sucker for a fresh baked, a little doughy, chocolate chip cookie.

[SSFan V]

[Roy Hobbs]

Ice cream.  It's more versatile, and does more for you on a hot day.  Also, cookies need something else (milk) to reach their full potential, while ice cream is cool on its own.

Plus, you can get cookie dough ice cream any day of the week.

[Evantime34]

Ice Cream, its not even close. Not even remotely close.

Completely agree.

[BballTim]

  I like those ice cream sandwiches with the ice cream between the big cookies...

[GKC]

Ice cream because it's the summer.

But wouldn't Cookies 'n Creme Ice Cream just solve everything?

[indeedproceed]

  I like those ice cream sandwiches with the ice cream between the big cookies...

Typical American greed. Have to have everything. Pfft.

[Neurotic Guy]

Depends on the cookie, the ice cream and.... the moment.  Certainly not a hands down for either.  Both, in the right context, can provide equal joy and satisfaction.

[indeedproceed]

Depends on the cookie, the ice cream and.... the moment.  Certainly not a hands down for either.  Both, in the right context, can provide equal joy and satisfaction.

Match with cookie, not using ice cream but using anything else:
Brownie Sundae, brownies warm, with fudge swirls inside, topped with vanilla ice cream, warm choc fudge, whipped cream, one cherry on top.

Match using only cookie:
Ben+Jerry's Phish Food ice cream.

It is not even close. it is absolutely a hands down for ice cream!