I think its a pretty cool idea, creating almost a "history" section of CB, we could try to dig up the first post ever on CB, the first post that Roy had to edit, the first time someone crashed the server, etc.
but the hall of fame, I like it - I don't know if you'd do 5 a year, or 1 a year, or 1 a quarter...who knows - I do think the names you named would all be very very solid candidates, others come to mind as well Redz, Bahku, Scintan, yourself, SShore (though we'd have to bring back his original retired sn), Florida... there's more, but yeah it'd be cool to do, the only thing I'd worry about with doing it as a poll is the politics that might go into it (we all saw the TP pageant) - but I think anyonymous nomination and voting could work... there could be qualifications to get in - like 5000 posts, 300 TPs or something like that, I dunno - but I do like it, I think it would be a nice way to cement those who have contributed in a special way
Now the big question - will they give CB a wing in Springfield? =)
Nice sentiments nick - classy stuff