Nick, I think this is a good idea, but I think it should be kept fun -- that is why we all come on here and make comments on a daily basis -- we love the Celtics, have fun talking about the Celtics, etc. We take the Celtics seriously, but we shouldn't take ourselves too seriously.
So, when you suggested the following:
There could be Threads of Fame, Posts of Fame, Subjects of Fame, and Articles of Fame.
It immediately came to mind that we could also have Threads of Shame
or Subjects of Shame
(ie: any thread after NBA 2008 Finals Game 6 that has to do with bringing back Gerald Green or Antoine Walker).
Also, a quick note regarding the amount of time someone has been a member of Celticsblog -- it is not entirely accurate to look at when their current profile was registered because some of us have changed names (I used to go by rcs34red -- and I suspect others have undergone name changes as well).