Very creative, and very self-serving. I agree with absolutely nothing you've said.
Your bigs don't defend. Gasol not at all, Odom not well. Perkins is an excellent defender, whether you want to admit it, and he's going to beat on Gasol from the opening tip of the game one until the final play. And when he's not beating on Gasol, P.J. Brown, Glen Davis and Leon Powe will be beating on him. Gasol is soft, and if you're basing dissent on his play against an over-the-hill Duncan, an old Camby and a Utah center who's just barely there, then I hope Gasol agrees with you. He's in for the surprise of his life.
You've got no answer defensively for Garnett. None at all. Garnett will score whenever he wants throughout this series. Odom can't stop Garnett. Gasol's below average defensively. I'd be more concerned about this matchup, frankly, if you had Bynum. Neither Gasol nor Odom is going to keep any offensive coach awake with their defense.
And Garnett's the defensive player of the year. He'll shut Odom down. And quite frankly, I fear Josh Smith's athleticism a lot more than anything Lamar Odom's indifferent game brings to the table.
As for Bryant, you seem to forget that he put up enough bricks in the first two games between these teams to build a house. He's going to see multiple defenders, and he's going to be frustrated. Count on it.
You have a nice team and this will be a good series. Just not as nice as you think.
Tim Duncan averaged almost 20 pts, 11 reb, and 2 blocks over the course of the season. How on earth did you conclude that he is over the hill? Gasol held Duncan to 40% shooting in the series, about 10% less than his season average. Was Gasol just lucky? No, amigo.
Oh and by the way, I wanted to point out a mistake I made earlier. Gasol guarded not Okur but all-star Carlos Boozer; and effectively, might I add?
As I pointed out earlier, Odom's game isn't predicated on scoring. The addition of Gasol has freed him from the responsibility of scoring and allowed his excellent passing and ball-handling skills to flourish. If Garnett wants to devote himself to locking up the 3rd option and never leave his side, that is fine with me. If he does, Gasol and Bryant will feast on Perkins and Allen. And if he doesn't then Odom likely contributes with cuts, rebounds, and easy putbacks.
I haven't forgotten Kobe's poor shooting against the Celtics earlier this season at all. If this were the same Laker team and the same Kobe Bryant, then I would expect more of the same. But that is not the case. The same high level of teamwork that makes the Celtics defense so impressive is mirrored by the teamwork and chemistry the Laker offense has today. There's a reason teams are reluctant to throw defenders at Kobe these days: MVP-level decision-making coupled with effective personnel. That tactic may have worked against Joe Johnson and the lowly and inexperienced Hawks, but not against the best team in the West.
I think I've been perfectly fair in my assessments. How realistic are you being? You, for example, think Tim Duncan is over the hill. If Duncan is over-the-hill, what is PJ Brown? And age hasn't stopped Camby from leading the league in blocks or averaging 13 rebounds. And the advantages Gasol has over the likes of Davis and Powe? I could make a list! Three that come to mind are height, speed, and skill.