There is a question as to how good is RJ Barrett.
He is sorta a tweener player. Like an oversized SG or an undersized SF. Never mastered a position. Never mastered a skill. A sold shooter but not an above average nevermind great shooter. Never developed his ball-handling and passing beyond a solid / capable level. Never developed his defense. A bit too slow in covering SGs and a bit too small in covering SFs.
He puts up numbers but there are real questions as to how much impact he actually has. As well as how dependable he can be. He goes missing for periods. You never know which version of him you are going to get. The consistent scorer or the inefficient underachiever.
----------
I was trying to figure out where to rank him among starting SGs and I was having a hard time picking a slot and feeling confident about it.
And the SG position is the weakest position in the league. A SG who can get 20ppg and has some level of all-around game should be comfortably in the top 10 or threatening the top 5. Yet ... I'm not convinced he is.
I feel more confident in D White at the SG position. I do have him threatening that top 5 ranking. Him and D Bane. Ant, D Mitchell, A Reaves is my top 3. S Castle, D White, D Bane my next 3. Then NAW (with McCollum starting PG) & Knueppel. Then Jrue (with Lillard starting at PG next year). That is my top 8.
Then I have some rankings of Nembhard, RJ Barrett, Lu Dort, Norm Powell, Amen Thompson. Then less consistent guys like Edgecombe & Zach LaVine.