This is Simmons' trade:
Simmons said. “The teams are the Boston Celtics and the Dallas Mavericks: Tim Hardaway and the No. 10 pick for Marcus Smart. And that’s the trade.”
I don't think this trade makes any sense. You expect that the Dallas backcourt is going to be Kyrie and Luka. Where does Marcus play? Off the bench? Does DAL go with 3 guards?
I will not be surprised if one of Smart, White, Brogdon are traded, but this is not going to be the deal. Maybe if Hardaway and #10 go to a third team, say IND or WAS, and we get Turner or Porzingis (I know something more would need to be in the deal for Porzingis), but not as Bill Simmons has it. And even with this version, which works better for BOS, I still don't see the fit for Marcus in DAL.
Yeah, I don't like it for Dallas. I understand the idea of getting a defender next to Luka & Kyrie but I don't like Smart's offensive game on that team. Not a good enough shooter to be enough of an off-ball threat. And with Luka & Kyrie, Smart will hardly ever get to make use of his ball-handling & passing abilities so his offensive game will largely be reduced to jump-shooting which is dodgy at. Not good.
I wouldn't give up the #10 pick for Smart due to his poor fit in Dallas' team. There are some good players available there at #10 who can have comparable long term value as Smart has had as a player. Better to hold the pick and use it.
For Boston
I am not wild about Tim Hardaway. He is a black hole type of player. A gunner who doesn't pass. He plays mediocre defense and gives mediocre rebounding. Yes, he can shoot the 3 but the rest of his game is lackluster. Even though he has wing size, he is no better defensively than playing Smart or D White at SG. In fact, he is worse. I worry about his non-passing on a team with Jaylen Brown and Tatum which will make good ball movement even harder.
I do like the #10 pick. That is the prize. I would trade Smart for the #10 pick if someone specific I wanted was available at that pick. So in this sense, I do the trade even though I am down on Tim Hardaway Jr. I would like to trade Hardaway elsewhere in subsequent deal rather than keep him but he would be a fine bench player if an adequate trade cannot be found.
So good for Boston, bad for Dallas. My take.