Idea: Brogdon for Smart, Timelord, Romeo

[KG Living Legend]

 Would you make this trade.

Horford, Thompson, Moses
Tatum
Brown
Fournier
Brogdon  21 ppg 6 apg 5.3 rpg

[liam]

 Would you make this trade.

Horford, Thompson,  Moses Malone
Tatum
Brown
Fournier
Brogdon  22 ppg 6 apg 5 rpg

Why?

Do we have Moses Malone?

[slamtheking]

Would you make this trade.

Horford, Thompson,  Moses Malone
Tatum
Brown
Fournier
Brogdon  21 ppg 6 apg 5.3 rpg

no, I would not.  too much for Brogdon.  good starter, but not worth Smart AND 2 prospects

[todd_days_41]

I’m not giving up Robert Williams in a deal like this, but I can see a deal built around Brogdon and Smart.

[KG Living Legend]

Would you make this trade.

Horford, Thompson,  Moses Malone
Tatum
Brown
Fournier
Brogdon  21 ppg 6 apg 5.3 rpg

no, I would not.  too much for Brogdon.  good starter, but not worth Smart AND 2 prospects

 I figure they would love Langford Indiana Legend,  and Smart so would you throw in a first for Brogdon if we keep Timelord

[gouki88]

I’d love Brogdon here. Has improved every year, can play scoring and facilitating roles, is very efficient and barely turns it over.

Not an amazing defender, so I would probably try and put Brown and Nesmith alongside him with Fournier off the bench, but I don’t mind that at all.

[PAOBoston]

In a heartbeat

[jpotter33]

Would love Brogdon here, though I think that's too steep of a price for all three. Smart + one other small asset/salary filler would be closer to equitable value I think, with hopefully Timelord not being that piece. Would hurt to lose Smart, but that's a trade that would potentially be worth it to fill out the roster.

That said, not sure why Indy would do it.

And Gouki, I thought Brogdon was a solid, above average defender, at least when he was in Milwaukee? Has he dropped off since going to Indy?

[footey]

No. Why is everyone trying to trade our 3rd and 4th best players ( Rob and Marcus)?  We become much worse defensively.

[Sophomore]

That's a steep price.

Also, Brogdon has had more than his share of injuries - he's missed significant time each of the past four years - and he turns 29 next season. I suppose everybody in that trade has had some injury issues, but Brogdon is the oldest.

[Ogaju]

Can you merge this thread with GreenlyGreen’s trade thread?

[slamtheking]

Would you make this trade.

Horford, Thompson,  Moses Malone
Tatum
Brown
Fournier
Brogdon  21 ppg 6 apg 5.3 rpg

no, I would not.  too much for Brogdon.  good starter, but not worth Smart AND 2 prospects

 I figure they would love Langford Indiana Legend,  and Smart so would you throw in a first for Brogdon if we keep Timelord

still too steep.  Smart and one prospect, maybe.   maybe Smart, Romeo and a first for Brogdon and Indy's first (or future first if Indy's pick is worse than the C's pick)

[wiley]

No. Why is everyone trying to trade our 3rd and 4th best players ( Rob and Marcus)?  We become much worse defensively.

Agree.  The board is cuckoo.  Throwing away excellent players right and left, slowly depleting our talent base.

[gouki88]

Would love Brogdon here, though I think that's too steep of a price for all three. Smart + one other small asset/salary filler would be closer to equitable value I think, with hopefully Timelord not being that piece. Would hurt to lose Smart, but that's a trade that would potentially be worth it to fill out the roster.

That said, not sure why Indy would do it.

And Gouki, I thought Brogdon was a solid, above average defender, at least when he was in Milwaukee? Has he dropped off since going to Indy?

He was that in Milwaukee, but his defence has fallen off a bit in Indiana. Makes some sense given he's not an elite athlete and his offensive role is much bigger in Indy. He's still not bad, and at his size (6'5, 230lbs) he can play on much bigger players than a lot of guards.

I think Smart, Langford, Edwards and a 2nd for Brogdon is decently fair value. I'm not sure how interested Indiana would be in a big given they've got Sabonis, Turner, and Bitadze (who was playing 17MPG over the last two months of the season).

[wiley]

Would love Brogdon here, though I think that's too steep of a price for all three. Smart + one other small asset/salary filler would be closer to equitable value I think, with hopefully Timelord not being that piece. Would hurt to lose Smart, but that's a trade that would potentially be worth it to fill out the roster.

That said, not sure why Indy would do it.

And Gouki, I thought Brogdon was a solid, above average defender, at least when he was in Milwaukee? Has he dropped off since going to Indy?

He was that in Milwaukee, but his defence has fallen off a bit in Indiana. Makes some sense given he's not an elite athlete and his offensive role is much bigger in Indy. He's still not bad, and at his size (6'5, 230lbs) he can play on much bigger players than a lot of guards.

I think Smart, Langford, Edwards and a 2nd for Brogdon is decently fair value. I'm not sure how interested Indiana would be in a big given they've got Sabonis, Turner, and Bitadze (who was playing 17MPG over the last two months of the season).

Smart and Langford together greater than Brogdon....imo.  Smart didn't have the best year, so people seems to have forgotten what peak Marcus looks like...it's quite something.
Langford is young and hungry.... and seems to be excellent on defense.  no way I ship him and Marcus for Brogdon at 29.