Yeah but that was mostly based on his age and doing things not done before based on that age. Statistically he is way down across the board this year. His last 8 games in particular, he has been a bottom 5 QB in several of the most meaningful metrics/statistics and that has never been the case in the past. Maybe he has a switch to flip, but after losing to the Dolphins I don't see how he does. They needed to win that game and came up epically short and Brady was bad. Brady just hasn't failed in must win games many times in his career and he came up lame in their most recent game.
I wouldn't be surprised if they beat the Titans, heck I might even give them the slight edge, but I'd be shocked if they beat the Chiefs at Arrowhead.
I get that you are one of the great contrarians in CB/CS history, but what is even the point right now? Even if Brady is done, why try your hardest to slam home the final nail in the coffin through age/stats. The Pats have literally just won 3 of the past 5 SBs and Brady has proven the world wrong time and again. People saying he's done and needs to retire sound foolish these days. It's been a broken record for years. He may not be as elite as he was in his prime, but he still has a little left in the tank. He certainly didn't look 'done' earlier in the season with some real weapons around him.
He’s not done unless he wants to be. Brady being among the top QBs in the league next year seems possible to me if he has a good O-line and weapons. Hope it’s with the Pats.
How many of you think he wouldn’t be among the top 8 in the league this year if he was QB for the Saints?
I don't, though he'd obviously be better if he had Michael Thomas to throw to. Though the Saints don't really have much outside of Michael Thomas to throw to. I mean an older TE and a RB had the 2nd and 3rd most receiving yards, followed by Ted Ginn and then another RB and their 3rd string QB that is a jack of all trades. Thomas is clearly awesome, but the Saints aren't exactly flush with pass catching talent outside of him.
Edit: Let's also be clear, the Patriots receiving group is better than several of the other top teams that ended up with much better QB play like the Seahawks, Packers, Titans (once Tannehill took over), and arguably teams like the Niners and Ravens (though they have solid TE's, they aren't good at WR).
I can't analyze the other teams too well as I haven't watched enough of them. But Edelman was a shell of himself over much of the last half of the season. After that the Pats had a group of 4th/5th receivers and a 39 yo tight end. I noticed you didn't dispute the O-line issue which in combination with a receiving core that had trouble running routes, trouble getting open and trouble catching the ball, is a quarterback's nightmare. Somehow TB had 22 TDs and 7 INTs and was the 16th ranked QB in total QB rating (fwiw). Yeah, maybe Saints with their other-worldly receiver, Ingram pretty solid at RB, 2 OK TEs, and solid/deep O-line wasn't the best example, but yeah Brady probably would have been top 8 with Saints offense.
By yards, the Patriots had the 8th ranked passing offense and were 18th in rushing which equated to 7th overall. Brady though was not a top 8 QB, despite having a top 8 passing offense overall.
That's because you are only looking at the stats and not the total context.
Brady threw the ball away to avoid sacks more than any other QB in the league. If instead of doing that he turtled and went to the ground, his passing stats would have looked a lot prettier but he would also have been playing much more stupid football...losing football.
Also factor in that the Pats led the league in dropped passes. If the receivers dropped passes at an average rate, again Brady's stats look prettier.
Then add in the context he had two rookies running wrong routes and threw the ball into empty space his receivers should have been in but weren't and you have probably 2-3 incompletions a game because of that.
Also, Brady was on and off the injury report the latter part of the year and looked like he was hurting against Miami(he was constantly shaking his throwing arm out on the sideline and avoided throwing long all day).
Brady declined statistically but a lot of that had to do with factors that had nothing to do with Brady's ability to be a top QB. I am not saying his age didn't lead to a decline of his abilities. It did. But not nearly as much as it is being made out to be.
It would not surprise me at all for Brady to have his 4th straight year of over 4000 yards passing after the age of 40 next year with over 25 TDs and a TD to INT ratio of greater than 3 to 1 while completing around 67% of his passes next year while playing intelligent, winning football.