Bird has more rings in a more competitive era. It's a pretty easy call
Guess that means Magic is significantly better than Bird then.
It would be very difficult to make an argument that Bird is better than Magic and he is usually ranked lower by the experts.
Magic was great---but he played in the West---Super weak division in the 80s...Of course the Lakers WALTZED to the Finals every year---while The Celtics were battling the 76ers..Pistons...Bucks...Hawks...Bulls....PLUS, they had to play these teams SIX times a year in the regular season---where the Lakers only had to play the Strong East teams Twice a year...So, Larry was easily Magic's equal at the least.
Right, but then when they played head to head it was 2-1 and he beat him in college and when you looked at the end of their careers on the Dream Team Magic was still an excellent player but Larry was hobbled. It's also 5 rings to three. It's not Manning vs Brady but there's a winner here.
It would have been 2-2 if Magic had upheld his end of the 1986 bargain. 
That's a good point
Magic got Worthy for 9 quality years
Bird got Bias for 2 ....... days
Magic left the game because unprotected sex with prostitutes
Bird left the game because he played hurt and dive for every ball
Magic became Lakers alpha dog in 1986/87
Bird became Celtics alpha dog from day one
And 4 Magic teammates from Michigan State would be starters on Indiana State team...
Bird had enough HOF teammates. Not sure the teammates argument works here.
Len Bias should be our answer to James Worthy. We lost in '87 2-4. In the end of the game 4 after Jabbar's missed FT it should be Celtics ball end there would be no Magic's baby hook.
We could gone to LA with 3-2 lead and who knows how would Lakers respond to presure?
And all that without Bias, without injured Walton and Wedman, with Parish on sprained ankle and McHale on broken foot.
And in playoffs we battled Jordan's Bulls, 7 games vs great Bucks team (Moncrief, Cummings, Sikma, Lucas, Pierce, Pressey, Hodges), 7 games vs even greater Pistons team (Thomas, Dumars, Dantley, Rodman, Laimbeer, Johnson, Mahorn and Salley).
Lakers faced Nuggets with old English, Fat Lever and 10 scrubs, Warriors with Sleepy Floyd and Joe Barry Carroll and solid Sonics team with McDaniel, Chambers and Ellis.
Bulls, Bucks and Pistons had combine records 142-104. Nuggets, Warriors and Sonics had combine records 118-128. Two of the tree teams Lakers faced was <50% teams.
If Celtics played in West...they would be in finals every year from 1980 thru 1988. And win at least 5 titles.