It's hard to believe, but Nate brought so much energy in that game six against Orlando, that I think he even one upped Eddie in that department.
Plus, I think he's more of a PG than Eddie and can shoot from inside the line, something Eddie was pretty bad at, actually. Nates probably got better shot selection, too.
Now, don't get me wrong, I loved Eddie and appreciate his loyalty, but I think I'd go with Nate 9.9 out of ten times.