At what point are people going to say that it's not ok for Smart to be shooting 36 percent?
Probably when he stops getting, at least, honorable mention votes for All NBA defensive team.
For a while he was making a difference on D. The refs have kind of put a stop to him there. He's not being allowed to use his body on D. Hopefully he makes an adjustment.
He always makes a difference on D. A few days ago, there was an article about Smart's stats from Chris Forsberg. He's 2nd among all point guards in defensive RPM, and over the past games holds his opponent to 41.4% shooting, which is well below the average. His impact is undeniable, both via the eye test and statistics.
Here's an excerpt:
Smart is unlikely to land on many Sixth Man of the Year ballots, but his impact on Boston's recent success is tangible. Zoom in on just the seven games since the All-Star break -- a 5-2 span for the Celtics -- and Smart leads the team in net rating at plus-10.1 points per 100 possessions. Boston's offensive rating is a crisp 108 with Smart on the court during that span, and that's balanced by a defensive rating of 97.9. What's more, Boston's pace cranks to 104.74 with Smart on the floor, the second-highest on the team in that span behind only Jae Crowder (105.7).
Further, to suggest that he should alter the way he plays defense because of poor officiating is silly. It's the other way around. Make officials adjust to YOUR game, which they eventually do as you progress beyond your rookie and sophomore years, particularly if you are an impact player and play a lot of minutes, both of which Smart is. Think KG for example, who sets a lot of illegal screens and often travels on spot-up shots (shuffles his feet to get his feet set in preparation to shoot).
Smart should continue to play extremely physical. If he gets called for fouls, so be it. Players have 6 fouls and shouldn't be afraid to use them. I don't mind him showing up an official for a bad call either. He's a fierce competitor and shouldn't be happy when he's on the receiving end of a bad call. It's when the complaining becomes constant (e.g. LeBron) that it is a problem.