I think the league needs to rethink second rounder contracts. Maybe make the contracts more uniform like first rounders. I can picture this trend getting out of hand quickly, and most second rounders opt'ing for that one year deal.
Perhaps, but I think that's unlikely in that it shifts the risk almost totally to the player to do that. I think KJ McDaniels' case was more rare:
KJ was a guy that was projected to be a late 1st roudner AND went to an awful 76ers team where he could more reasonably expect playing time than most other 2nd rounders. And IIRC Heinke's 4-year 2nd round deals are all 1 year + 3 semi-or-non-guaranteed.
IMO, if Mickey (or any 2nd rounder) is offered a 3 year guaranteed deal (like we did with Ryan Gomes back in the day), i think it'll be 98 times out of 100 that they take the guarantee. It guarantees them not just the money (tho less than a 1st rounder) but the chance to prove their worth to the team.
For a 2nd rounder to take a 1 year deal only they will have to assume they will (a) get some semblance of playing time and (b) not suffer an injury that could keep them from getting a 2nd contract.
I guess I can see the argument that even in the worst case scenario, a 2nd rounder (esp. in the new, larger cap era) has to just flash enough *potential* for a team to take a chance on a, say, 2yr $5M contract. But keep in mind that there will be 30 more 2nd rounders coming into the league the following year and that still ignores the fairly large risk McDaniels took.
That he succeeded, or dodged that risk, i don't think will usher in a new era of players doing the same.
Morey overpaid. McDaniels hadn't proven that he's rotation-worthy yet.
It's of course a very small sample size, but I'd disagree. McDaniels has shown to be a defender ahead of most other young players. It's at worst a good gamble by Morey IMO, but I think will turn out to an excellent value contract (3yr $10 now is like $3yrs 6 was before, right)
His rookie season was arguably better than his teammate (and not-bad-comp) Corey Brewer:
http://bkref.com/tiny/P3iiB