I agree -- K-Love should play bench role if he returns to Cleveland. Tristan Thompson has transformed their team defense. K-Love as 3rd option scorer does not provide as much as Thompson has given the Cavs since K-Love went down. Let K-Love be 6th man.
Which is where the predicament lies. We were lucky enough to have IT buy into being a top 6th man in this league, but Love already knows what it's like to be a [near] superstar. I can't imagine he wants to come off the bench. I realize there have been great 6th men in the history of the NBA, but Love doesn't seem like he is buying into it just yet.
Expect a sign and trade to a team like the Cs where Cleveland gets a first and TPE - that way Love gets his starring role and also looks like a nice guy without leaving Cleveland high and dry.
I expect Love to take a max deal in Cleveland where he maxes out his earnings and wins 3 or 4 championship rings, waltzing his way into the Hall of Fame. I mean, is his desire to "get his" worth more than millions of dollars in salary, even more in endorsements, and being remembered as part of great championship teams?
I do not think Love will make a bad financial decision. What I mean by this is that Love will not sign a long term contract with anyone this offseason. I expect him to be back in cleveland after opting in.
You have well covered how his current situation could be great and opting in lets him give it another shot and also allows him to, even if he has a bad year, sign a megadeal next summer.
However, I disagree on several points. First off, the endorsements. Being the 3rd option and probably the 4th or 5th most popoular player on a Cleveland team does not equal huge endorsements regardless of how good that team is.
If he wants fame and fortune he will go to another NBA team. Perhaps a team in LA or NY. Even being the no. 1 option in Boston or a team like Detroit probably brings more endorsement money than Cleveland would.
Lastly, getting his is incredibly important. Staying in Cleveland means sacrificing touches and minutes in exchange for a chance to be remembered as that other guy who was pretty good on those Cavs teams that won a few rings and the privelage to be blamed for just about everything that goes wrong.