As one of the biggest Gordon homers around here, I've been warming up to Randle the past few days.
I think he absolutely can be an All Star.
The thing to remember is that he faced more double teams than anybody in college basketball last season. In the NBA, he'll be surrounded by better shooters at every position, so he will see less double teams.
His quickness is indeed underrated, and he is going to put up a lot of efficient points in the NBA, and get to the line a lot.
I was a little put off by his energy level that seemed to wane for long stretches when he played big minutes last year. The key with him I think is to play him in 5 minute stretches like we used to do with old KG. This way Randle can play all-out, his defense will be better, and he'll know a rest is forthcoming.
In short 5 minute stints like this, I think Randle could even play some minutes at SF. Part of the reason I'm so high on Gordon to Boston is because Gordon is already awesome scoring around the basket, and with Sully and KO spreading the floor, Gordon could play a Power 3 role on offense.
Well, I think Randle could also play that power 3 role in short minutes against certain matchups, and just crush SFs in the paint and on the boards.
Randle could also play some minutes as a small ball center in an uptempo unit, so there is a bit of versatility to Randle.
I'd be happy with quite a few guys at #6, and Randle is certainly one of them. Even as a rookie he is going to surprise and impress with his ability to put up lots of points, and he could definitely be a 20/10 guy in short order.