They are both RFA's right?
I'd probably see how much they will command in the open market first. About $8 million a year for both is probably the price I'd be willing to pay (I think that's a bit overpaying already too but I don't mind). Anything less, absolute MATCH. But more than $8 million for each, I'd probably just keep one, and I'm leaning Crawford.
As long as Crawford plays in this level, and Bradley still be the pitbull that he is, $16 million per year for your SG rotation is not bad.