Help me out here. What are you guys seeing?
Enough to make me think he can provide some useful minutes this year. He looked like a complete liability most of the time I saw him play minutes in preseason and first two regular season games so that is a big improvement over those early bad signs.
Defensively, I don't trust him against anyone who will attack him. But I think he has shown enough team defense to stay out there against limited to mediocre offensive threats. Shows good mobility. Stays in position well enough. Doing a bit better in man-to-man defense but I still don't trust that hold up if anyone really went at him (which they haven't in last two games). Has good size at 7-0 feet if not bulk/length and it did seem like players were surprisingly (wrongly) reluctant to attack him at times. So it is aggressive attackers I would be worried about.
Rebounding wise, Olynyk was dreadful in preseason and against Toronto. Not only not grabbing rebounds but frequently being outworked by the guy he was meant to be boxing out and losing position to him. Shown much more fight in staying between his man and the ball last two games. Grabbed some more rebounds.
So in terms of defense and rebounding, I thought was fairly awful to begin with but has reached a more passable level in last two games. Below average but passable.
Offensively, I don't worry too much about the offense.
I think perimeter bigs like Olynyk often struggle (1) when they first come to the NBA (2) when they play low and/or inconsistent minutes. So his struggles with his jump-shot don't worry me at this point. I think it is something that will gradually progress. Whether it happens over the next few weeks or months or whether it is next season, I do think that jump-shot will be there long term.
On the plus side, I think his passing has been very good. Best passing big man on the team. He has some ball-handling too. Shows some nifty footwork 10 feet and below. Beat Greg Monroe a couple of times in one-on-one situations. Makes nice cuts off the ball and uses his mobility/agility and soft touch to good effect to wiggle around defenders and get off shots. Seems to create a fair bit of contact too. Surprised by how many fouls he has drawn around the basket. Smart player. High IQ.
I feel confident Olynyk can create an advantage for Boston against limited offensive backup big men but I don't trust him against strong offensive threats. I think he will often become a liability against them. If matchups are controlled well by coaching staff, I think he can be useful.
Needs to maintain recent improved rebounding efforts to be of value. If he reverts back to where his rebounding previously was, he'll be too much of a net negative (short of much improved offense).