Very well said. TP.
PG: Rondo (20/13/6/1)
SG:
SF: Green (24/6/2)
PF:
C:
In what dimension do they average those stats
Agreed. Good lord. I love Rondo too, but take the green-tinted glasses off for a second. The only three players who have ever averaged 13 APG for a season are Magic, Stockton, and Isiah, and the only one who's done it more than once is Stockton, and anyone who says Rondo-to-Green is anywhere in the same vicinity as Stockton-to-Malone is kidding themselves.
As for the OP's argument, I think you're being a little melodramatic here as well. I think Paul versus Rondo for who's the better PG is an interesting debate; I'd take Paul for now by a hair until Rondo becomes a better shooter, but I can't fault someone for picking Rondo instead. But where you lose all credibility is by suggesting that Green is a better player than Griffin. I'm sorry, but you're just wrong. At best, Griffin and Green are equal, but Green has shown absolutely nothing since he's came into the league to suggest that he's anything more than a solid complementary player. I like him, and I like having him on the Celtics, but he's nowhere near the cornerstone that Griffin is, and I think it's clear because there are A LOT more teams lining up to trade for Griffin than for Green, and it has very little to do with his contract.
I mean, I'm not even sure Green is anything better than a middle-of-the-pack starter at the moment. You're saying that Green is better than Griffin
right now, so let's assume we're talking one season, in a vacuum, no injuries. Assuming we list Green as a PF, I would argue that the following PFs -- in no particular order beyond stating that everyone listed is, in my opinion, better than him at the moment -- would be as follows (keeping in mind that I'm listing Duncan as a C but KG as a PF):
Garnett
Griffin
Z-Bo
Aldridge
Josh Smith
Lee
Love
West
Dirk
Ibaka
Tobias Harris
Thaddeus Young
Faried
... and an argument might be able to be made for Gasol, Boozer, Ilyasova, and Anthony Davis depending on tastes.
Now let's call Green a SF and do the same exercise, again in particular order beyond saying they're better than Green:
Lebron
Durant
Melo
Paul George
Pierce
Rudy Gay
Batum
Parsons
Iguodala
Kawhi Leonard
Deng
... and maybe Gallinari, and I'd call Turner about equal. Shorter than the PF list, no doubt, but still a long list.
Given all that, how can you suggest that Green is better than Griffin? In 5 years, perhaps Green can make up enough ground and Griffin can regress, but what evidence have we been given so far to suggest that Green will grow much beyond what he was the year before the heart surgery and this past year? Remember that we all though Tony Allen was going to be an amazing SG based on what he did for a string of games before injuring himself a few years back, but he never delivered on that promise (he's a great defensive SG, sure, but no one's rooting for his offense.) At some point we have to recognize the realities of the players we have. Green seems like a great guy to be around, and he's a good player, but he's not a great one. He's a #3 option, at best, on a contending team.