I'm impartial. When he catches the ball cleanly he does some good things.
Seriously was irritated with his hands all season, though.
I don't think he has bad hands, I just don't think he's good at figuring out when a pass might come his way. He's never ready for the pass.
I think it is a little of both. You're right, he doesn't seem as ready for passes as he should be. But, he also seems to get the ball stripped a lot too, which to me is somewhat an indication of his hands.