I'm pretty sure I hate Kobe as much as anyone here does but it's crazy that his talent would drop to my pick.
5 rings, 14 time All Star, 10 All NBA 1st teams, 9 All NBA Def 1st teams, 5th in points all time....and....he's teaching Jerry Rice how to make no handed catches!!
Welcome to Chicago Mr. Mamba!
In my mind, there are really only 2 major drawbacks on Kobe.
1) In any of his championship seasons, he was never the MVP. So when you're picking a year for him, you're probably picking a year when he won (probably his Finals MVP year), but maybe not when he was at his absolute peak.
2) He's a volume shooter whose usage rates have always been so high, you need to be careful who you build around him with, as much as you would with a guy like LeBron.