To be clear, the rules are that any player that played from 1985 until the present is eligible, correct?
I think folks might be over-thinking this a bit, to let the near-consensus (i.e., outside of Boston) best player of all-time fall to #3.
EDIT: Okay, I see. Even though the rules say this:
Each player will be assigned a team and run that team as it's owner. Players to be drafted will be any player that played from 1985 until the present. Once a player is drafted he is the property of that team. Once all rounds of the draft are over, each owner will be required to submit a roster picking the season that each of his or her players will be represented by. The season chosen must be a season within the time frame of the era, in this case, 1985-86 to-2011-2012.
... the real intent is for this to be for players drafted in '85 and after?