How dare players use free agency to determine what the best situation for them to work is! HOW DARE THEY! Who do they think they are? Americans?
free agency is one thing, but what the players have been doing in recent seasons basically undermines the ability of GMs to actually plan how they want to build their team.
i know some people are not at all bothered by the idea of the players being the GMs, but to me that's a pretty sad state of affairs. i want a league where the best teams are the ones that are best managed, not the ones that all the best players decided to flock to.
Would you have this same feeling in any other business?
No! But this is not any other business!
This is a professional sports league with 30 teams that are all supposedly meant to have a realistic shot at competing.
No, no it's not. All 30 teams are not supposed to be able to compete for a title. The only way to do that is to spread the talent so thin that the product would be nigh unwatchable.
There is no logical complaint or quarrel one can have with people who work in the same field wanting to work together to reach new heights in that field.
Sure there is. You can't treat the NBA, or any other professional sports league, as if it is a job market like any other. It operates totally differently.
The better analogy is that the NBA is one large business and the teams are sub-sets of that business. The business makes money by entertaining fans, and each sub-set is an integral part of the product that the NBA offers.
A league governed entirely by free market principles would be a joke of competitive balance. Just look at European soccer leagues.
By "meant to have a realistic shot at competing," by the way, I don't mean in a given season. That's obviously not the case. But the idea is that each team operates under more or less the same rules with more or less the same resources. The best teams should be the ones that do the most under those rules with those resources, not who has the most money, the best location, or the star with the most friends.