I have Direct, Roy. For me and where I live it's the best option. The local cable doesn't have NBA ticket or NFL ticket nor a way to see the C's. I live in a rural area in SE Kentucky. So I only have three choices, Dish, DirecTV or local cable. I choose DirectTV over both because I get the channels I want. Dish is cheaper.
Here is a good tool to compare Dish and DirectTV
http://www.direct-vs-dish.com/http://www.dishcomparison.com/dish-network-vs-directv.phpHere is the deal with local channels and a website to take a look at both of them.
http://www.dishtvtips.com/directv-local-channels.htmlHere is the law governing local channels something you will want to be aware of:
http://transition.fcc.gov/mb/shva/shviafac.htmlI got the Whole Home DVR setup with the internet box. This is the deal I got:
http://www.directv.com/DTVAPP/new_customer/base_packages.jsp?footernavtype=-1I have it in four rooms with all the pay per channels save the adult ones for three months free. After that my bill will go up some. Right now it's about 70 bucks for 270 channels but will go well over 100 after the three month trial to keep the movie channels.
My system does have VOD and it is DirectTV. I have the internet box for Direct Cinema. On it I can watch movies that are relatively new for 5.99. They have older movies ranging from 3.99 to 5.99. A new movie for them would be Cowboys vs. Aliens or Capt. America. I believe they have 6K movies presently in their stocks. I can download any movie on Starz, HBO, Showtime with my internet connection for free instead of waiting for them to come on. This also works for TV shows, for instance, I missed the finale to Topshot season 3 but was able to download it the next day and watch it on demand. This works only if the programming is in the rotation.
I have the NFL ticket which rocks. I get the NBA pass which rocks. I am able to watch the 60 regional sports channels through the sports package even though I live 907 miles from Bean Town. I get to watch Celtics Now this way and the pregame shows.
I seen Dish TV at my mom's. She saw my DirectTV and switched over to it. It's an individual choice between the too. DirectTV is number one in satelitte service in number of customers and is adding more than Dish. Dish has 13.9 million and DirectTV has 19.8 million. Comcast is the only bigger pay TV provider. The reason why is DirectTV has the NFL ticket and if you don't want it then pick the cheaper of the two. I had to get it for my wife.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/dish-network-3rd-quarter-earnings-climb-30-percent-subscriber-total-falls/2011/11/07/gIQAIv7wuM_story.htmlOne cool think is on the HD DVR you really can pause or rewind any show your watching even live sports events with the DirectTV. I did it yesterday watching football a lot when the network didn't show replays I wanted to see. I will probably be all over the refs even more with blown calls this year with this ability.
I can't say what is best for you. I have found my experience pleasant with Direct TV and it's the best option for me, personally. Good luck in your decision, hope this helps you out...