I just looked at Ray/Paul's season stats, they both should be in. Especially with Joe Johnson and Granger's sub par play.
Guards:
Rondo
Wade
Rose
Felton
Forwards:
LeBron
KG
Amar'e
Pierce
Boozer
Horford
Centers:
Howard
Noah
Is probably what I'd put it at, though I'm not in love with the idea that Felton would be an all-star. I can easily see Ray getting left out for Granger/Joe Johnson. Boozer/Noah could both miss due to injury but should make it. Josh Smith also should have a shot at sneaking in.
Ray Allen should easily make it over felton, especially with Rondo and Rose already making it .
Ray's stats = 17.5PPG, 3.3AST, 0.9STL, 50%FG, 44%3PT FG, 87%FT
Felton's stats =18ppg, 8.7ast, 1.8stl, 45%FG,3 4%3PT FG, 86%FT
Ray is putting up the best fg% and 3pt fg% of his career. I don't think there is any way he doesn't make it .