I don't think that team's any better in year one that PP/KG/RA/RR, and if they don't win a title in the first year or two James will just opt out again. And this is predicated on LeBron and Bosh choosing Perk (injured), Hedo and Calderon over Rose, Noah and Gibson.
Well, agree to disagree, I think that team is absolutely better than boston's last year and quite a bit better than lebron's cleveland team last year. especially once you add the vet mins: rasual butler, joe smith, etc.
as for chicago, that's debateable. Rose is a better talent than calderon, no doubt, and i'd take noah over perk. but baby's still here, turkoglu is a great 3rd option especially next to lebron (he rebounds a little, is still a deadly distance shooter, and distributes too), and i like calderon next to james better than rose on offense; shares better and is a great outside shooter while rose is ok.
We were a lot better than Cleveland as well. And Calderon's a defensive liability, putting it mildly.
Basically, you upgrade Pierce to James - big upgrade now and even bigger moving forward - and Garnett to Bosh - I'm really not sure how big an upgrade that actually is or whether it's one at all short term; for the future, big upgrade - and take big downgrades from Rondo to Calderon - I do see that his offensive skills could jibe with Lebron but his defense is atrocious and we all saw over the past two years with Mo Williams how well a shooter who can't defend fares as point guard next to Lebron, and for the future it could be an even bigger disparity as Calderon appears to be what he is while Rondo is still growing - and from Ray to Hedo - as old as Ray is, he has more good years left in him than Hedo, who absolutely cannot play shooting guard and is on an atrocious contract that will cripple the team in the future. Honestly, I don't think Lebron or Bosh would look at that situation and say, "yeah, that looks good."
Besides, Rondo is an unnecessary component to this deal. Toronto would be happy to give us Bosh to swap out Garnett and his two remaining years (giving them a defensive power forward next to Bargnani) for Turkoglu and his atrocious contract, or Calderon and his atrocious contract (Toronto's choice; I'd prefer Calderon they'd probably prefer to deal Hedo's washed up chain smoking body and extra contract year). We can include Davis instead of Rondo to make the deal work financially.
Of course, we can't sign Lebron outright anyway, so this discussion is, essentially, pointless.