Author Topic: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments  (Read 87939 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #255 on: May 27, 2010, 03:54:48 PM »

Offline riah32

  • Jayson Tatum
  • Posts: 888
  • Tommy Points: 94
Anyone wanna take a shot and do my write up for pm me and i'll give you a quick summary so you can do it.
Indiana Pacers-Celticsblog Draft Team

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #256 on: May 27, 2010, 04:04:30 PM »

Online Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 53006
  • Tommy Points: 2571
Why Oak over J.O? / The Bench Section

I know, I know, I know: I've been saying Jermaine over Oak for the entire excercise. And while I do still believe that the difference between the two's offensive game is greater than the defensive difference (at-least in their primes), I think J.O is more suited for the bench in this excercise.

With Nash, Garnett, T-Mac and to a lesser extent Spree, the starting lineup has enough offensive fire power in it. So I thought it was probably best to move J.O's strong post set to the bench where he could be a more featured offensive option, and brought the defensive brickhouse known as Charles Oakley to the starting lineup. I think him and KG are a tremendous compliment to each other and would match up very well defensively even against the strongest of front courts.

I think at the end of the day, the split of the minutes will be even and who plays at the end would be dependent on matchups and feel.

For the most part, even though I've listed some players "Definitive minutes" I wouldn't expect huge minutes out of anyone on the bench with the exception of Jermaine O'Neal. That being said, each has a very defined role which I think is farily obvious when you take a look at them: Knock down shooters, wing defenders, bruisers and playmakers. These are generic terms for any role players, but a lot of these guys are the embodiment of those generic terms, which is why I think they'd plug in so well to these great lineups.
I didn't like this decision at first but looking across the Western Conference that center position isn't nearly as strong as in the East. I think Oakley can play this position at a high enough level to make this change work in your team's favour.

Oakley is an excellent defender against Bosh + Amare and is a solid defender against Mutombo due to Deke's limited offensive repertoire ... but will struggle against Yao, Mourning and Shaq. Jermaine was outclassed by at least two of those players anyway so their is little difference here.

Moving Jermaine O'Neal to the main backup big man slot will make him one of the most talented in the Conference. Arguably the single most talented player.

With Nash, McGrady and Garnett ... the squad has enough offense in their starting lineup to live with the downgrade + I thought the team's bench failed to create any matchup advantages against Western Conference opponents and needed an upgrade talent wise. Jermaine does that.

Good change.

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #257 on: May 27, 2010, 04:13:52 PM »

Online Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 53006
  • Tommy Points: 2571
3.) The season I chose of McDyess' was 2000-01. He was 26 years old and already a six year veteran. It was his most efficient and well rounded year and he was already starting to become a better defender and all around player. This wasn't the McDyess of 1997-98 who was all slamming and nothing else. You are mischaracterizing what Dice was at that portion of his career.
Agreed

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #258 on: May 27, 2010, 04:18:34 PM »

Offline misha

  • Jim Loscutoff
  • **
  • Posts: 2898
  • Tommy Points: 1488
  • Open your eyes
BTW can we talk already about players that wasn't selected?
The Immortals:

Iker Casillas, Giacinto Facchetti, Alessandro Nesta, Matthias Sammer, Javier Zanetti, Lothar Matthäus (c), Xavi, Zico, Maradona, Roberto Baggio, Ferenc Puskas, Karl Heinz Rummenigge

Coach:Rinus Michels

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #259 on: May 27, 2010, 04:25:31 PM »

Offline Roy Hobbs

  • In The Rafters
  • The Natural
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 33333
  • Tommy Points: 6430
  • Doc could learn a thing or two from Norman Dale
BTW can we talk already about players that wasn't selected?

I believe so, yep.

Lots of good ones that were left.  I personally like Kevin Duckworth and Tom Gugliotta.  Other players that may have helped teams:  Starbury, Monta Ellis, Tyreke Evans, Wally Sczerbiak, etc.

All the negativity in this town sucks. It sucks, and it stinks, and it sucks. - Rick Pitino

Portland CrotoNats:  2009 CB Draft Champions

Re: CB Historical Draft Presentation
« Reply #260 on: May 27, 2010, 04:28:13 PM »

Online Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 53006
  • Tommy Points: 2571
Strategy

Having Magic Johnson fall to me at #10 in the first round set me in the direction that I decided to go.  From there, I decided that I'd try and build a team around athleticism and size.  I watched some of my fellow owners construct some incredible front-courts and decided that I needed to draft guys with size that could provide toughness in defending them.  I chose to take a young Patrick Ewing that was a an incredible defensivice force rather than the more refined offensive player we saw in the mid-90s.  I assumed I'd be able to compensate offesnisivley with my backcourt and wings.

I feel like this team can excel offensively in either the half-court set or playing up-tempo.  I have arguabley the greatest PG ever to run the fast break as well as 2 athletic players in 'Nique and Kemp that can run and finish with authority.  Quite the dangerous trio in the open court.

I think I have a very strong bench that can come in at any time with very little drop-off.  Ginobili is one of the greatest 6th men of the past 20 years and Dale Davis brings his huge physical frame and toughness to counter some of these incredible front-courts.  Raojn Rondo offers the ultimate change up in PGs in contrast to Magic.  Its like throwing a knuckleballer out there after facing a flamethrower all day.  As we've seen this season and playoffs, Rondo has clearly emerged as a Top 5 PG and I couldn't think of a much better backup to Magic.  Amazingly, I actually get bigger when I sub Sabonis' 7 foot 3 frame in there for Ewing.  Sabonis is one of the all-time great passing big men and can hit the outside shot that will draw some of these opposing big men out of the paint, thus allowing my wings to make their way to the basket.

I think a coach like Chuck Daly is perfect for this team.  The man was a master of managing egos and the Original Dream Team was the ultimate collection of stars and you couldn't have asked for a more perfect job.  I don't think chemistry will be an issue on this team.  I have drafted a bunch of key role players from championship teams that know their roles and may be used just for situational circumstances.  I have no doubt they'll accept those roles.


Two thoughts ...

(1) I was disappointed that the Bucks didn't get a high end versatile perimeter defender to play alongside and hide Magic Johnson. A 6-7/6-8 type with great quickness and length who can cover all three perimeter positions at a high level.

I think Richmond's defense drops off considerably (good to poor) if forced to defend the quick talented point guards (suspect quickness relative to position) that Magic Johnson cannot adequately defend. I like Wilkins to cover either wing spot though.

(2) I would play Ginobili as my lead backup guard and Danny Granger as my main backup wing. Go with a five man perimeter rotation. Then use one or two of Dale Davis, Joakim Noah and/or Arvydis Sabonis as your first choice backup bigs based on matchups. Sometimes Sabonis is too slow so you'll need a second big in your rotation some nights. I'm not sure whether I'd take Davis or Noah for that role. Either one is great. Could also go with Horford, there is not much between the three of them.

But I would leave Rajon Rondo out of the rotation ... I think your team is stronger with a bigger perimeter rotation led by Ginobili and Granger. Plus I love their shooting ability. Ginobili is an excellent point guard. I would also give Manu more minutes than Richmond. And, having Rondo as a third string guard is a nice weapon to turn to if things aren't going well. Completely change the dynamics of the game.

I think if you use that rotation you have the strongest bench in the competition. Actually, you may have that anyway, but I think that is your best rotation.

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #261 on: May 27, 2010, 04:28:41 PM »

Offline misha

  • Jim Loscutoff
  • **
  • Posts: 2898
  • Tommy Points: 1488
  • Open your eyes
Toni Kukoc could have been a nice addition to some teams.
The Immortals:

Iker Casillas, Giacinto Facchetti, Alessandro Nesta, Matthias Sammer, Javier Zanetti, Lothar Matthäus (c), Xavi, Zico, Maradona, Roberto Baggio, Ferenc Puskas, Karl Heinz Rummenigge

Coach:Rinus Michels

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #262 on: May 27, 2010, 04:33:18 PM »

Offline nickagneta

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 48121
  • Tommy Points: 8800
  • President of Jaylen Brown Fan Club
BTW can we talk already about players that wasn't selected?
Go right ahead talk about players that weren't selected and were selected.

Re: CB Historical Draft Presentation
« Reply #263 on: May 27, 2010, 04:45:40 PM »

Offline Donoghus

  • Global Moderator
  • Walter Brown
  • ********************************
  • Posts: 32782
  • Tommy Points: 1732
  • What a Pub Should Be
Strategy

Having Magic Johnson fall to me at #10 in the first round set me in the direction that I decided to go.  From there, I decided that I'd try and build a team around athleticism and size.  I watched some of my fellow owners construct some incredible front-courts and decided that I needed to draft guys with size that could provide toughness in defending them.  I chose to take a young Patrick Ewing that was a an incredible defensivice force rather than the more refined offensive player we saw in the mid-90s.  I assumed I'd be able to compensate offesnisivley with my backcourt and wings.

I feel like this team can excel offensively in either the half-court set or playing up-tempo.  I have arguabley the greatest PG ever to run the fast break as well as 2 athletic players in 'Nique and Kemp that can run and finish with authority.  Quite the dangerous trio in the open court.

I think I have a very strong bench that can come in at any time with very little drop-off.  Ginobili is one of the greatest 6th men of the past 20 years and Dale Davis brings his huge physical frame and toughness to counter some of these incredible front-courts.  Raojn Rondo offers the ultimate change up in PGs in contrast to Magic.  Its like throwing a knuckleballer out there after facing a flamethrower all day.  As we've seen this season and playoffs, Rondo has clearly emerged as a Top 5 PG and I couldn't think of a much better backup to Magic.  Amazingly, I actually get bigger when I sub Sabonis' 7 foot 3 frame in there for Ewing.  Sabonis is one of the all-time great passing big men and can hit the outside shot that will draw some of these opposing big men out of the paint, thus allowing my wings to make their way to the basket.

I think a coach like Chuck Daly is perfect for this team.  The man was a master of managing egos and the Original Dream Team was the ultimate collection of stars and you couldn't have asked for a more perfect job.  I don't think chemistry will be an issue on this team.  I have drafted a bunch of key role players from championship teams that know their roles and may be used just for situational circumstances.  I have no doubt they'll accept those roles.


Two thoughts ...

(1) I was disappointed that the Bucks didn't get a high end versatile perimeter defender to play alongside and hide Magic Johnson. A 6-7/6-8 type with great quickness and length who can cover all three perimeter positions at a high level.

I think Richmond's defense drops off considerably (good to poor) if forced to defend the quick talented point guards (suspect quickness relative to position) that Magic Johnson cannot adequately defend. I like Wilkins to cover either wing spot though.

(2) I would play Ginobili as my lead backup guard and Danny Granger as my main backup wing. Go with a five man perimeter rotation. Then use one or two of Dale Davis, Joakim Noah and/or Arvydis Sabonis as your first choice backup bigs based on matchups. Sometimes Sabonis is too slow so you'll need a second big in your rotation some nights. I'm not sure whether I'd take Davis or Noah for that role. Either one is great. Could also go with Horford, there is not much between the three of them.

But I would leave Rajon Rondo out of the rotation ... I think your team is stronger with a bigger perimeter rotation led by Ginobili and Granger. Plus I love their shooting ability. Ginobili is an excellent point guard. I would also give Manu more minutes than Richmond. And, having Rondo as a third string guard is a nice weapon to turn to if things aren't going well. Completely change the dynamics of the game.

I think if you use that rotation you have the strongest bench in the competition. Actually, you may have that anyway, but I think that is your best rotation.

Thanks for the feedback, Who.  Much appreciated.

Trust me, I was definitely look for a defense-oriented 2 but kinda struck out in that department. A couple of guys would've been great but were snatched up by other owners Ending up settling with Richmond and Ginobili and decided to throw caution to the wind and "run & gun".  I think my team strengths can go great lengths to cover up perimeter defense, which I agree is my #1 concern. 

I definitely had a difficult time coming up with a rotation and it could definitely vary depending on who I'm matching up against.  I think Ginobili is the biggest no-brainer but there is plenty of room left for debate with everyone else.  I see where you're coming from with your stance on Rondo but its awfully tough to pass on him considering his level of play much of this season.  Plus, I like the idea of total contrast between him & Magic.  I do like your idea of rotating the bigs depending on matchups.  I absolutely love my frontcourt guys (starters, subs, and reserves).  I don't think I can really go wrong with who I trot out there at the 4 and the 5.

I do think, regardless of rotations, that I have the deepest bench in this exercise.  Bar none.


2010 CB Historical Draft - Best Overall Team

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #264 on: May 27, 2010, 04:49:05 PM »

Offline Redz

  • Punner
  • Global Moderator
  • Red Auerbach
  • *******************************
  • Posts: 31749
  • Tommy Points: 3846
  • Yup
BTW can we talk already about players that wasn't selected?

I believe so, yep.

Lots of good ones that were left.  I personally like Kevin Duckworth and Tom Gugliotta.  Other players that may have helped teams:  Starbury, Monta Ellis, Tyreke Evans, Wally Sczerbiak, etc.

Was Darrell Armstrong taken?  He was a guy I was looking at with my last pick.  I wanted a gritty vet who would give it his all.  I ended up going with Bo Outlaw because he was just an animal in his prime.
Yup

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #265 on: May 27, 2010, 05:48:34 PM »

Offline RebusRankin

  • Satch Sanders
  • *********
  • Posts: 9143
  • Tommy Points: 923
San Antonio's write up comming later.

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #266 on: May 27, 2010, 08:13:03 PM »

Offline stoyko

  • Jrue Holiday
  • Posts: 399
  • Tommy Points: 77
76ers in Review aka Fo, Fo, Fo
The overall goal of my team was to pick the most efficient seasons for my players making an offensive and defensive Juggernaut.I tried to pick years when my players sacrificed for the common good and were the most efficient (see PP, Gasol, and Rasheed).  Depending on the matchup, the Sixers may start either Wallace or Walker to give the front court more outside offense. Mckey, Hawkins, and Blaylock are first 3 subs then the bigs.The Sixers will run when able especially with the second unit. Elden Campbell will play more minutes when Wallace and Walker get ejected.

Coach Poppovich always get the most out of his crew and is pumped to have more weapons to complement Tim "Title" Duncan. Considering Popp managed Stephen Jackson successfully he and tri-captains GP, TD, and PP should manage the more volatile players (Walker, Wallace, and GP).

PG
Gary Payton, the Glove, will be my starting point guard. In the 1997-8 season not only was he 1st Team NBA and 1st Team Defense, he averaged 17.2 pts, 8.3 ast, 4.6 rebs, and 2.3 steals a game. GP will hit the 3, find the open man, and lock down the opposing team's point guard.
SG
Brandon Roy, gets the nod at starting shooting guard. In the 2008-9 season, this All Star and 3rd Team All NBA was the 7th most efficient player in the NBA, was top 3 in offensive win shares, and averaged 22.6 points, 5.1 assists, 4.7 rebounds, while shooting 47 percent from the field, 37.7 percent from 3 point land, and 82.4 percent from the line.
SF
Paul Pierce, the Captain and the Truth, gets the start at small forward. The cagey veteran played perhaps the best basketball of his life in 2007-8, and since adjusting to the New Big 3 was so easy, he should be able to join the star studded Sixers as well. This 2nd Team All NBA and Finals MVP is the perfect complementary player, rising to the occasion of the big game while averaging 20.6 points a game, 5.1 rebounds, and 4.7 assists. Got a title drought? Give him the right team mates and he'll solve it.
PF
Tim "Title Town" Duncan is the starting PF. You might remember his coming out party in 2001-2. League MVP, All Star, 1st Team ALL NBA and Defensive. Oh yeah and don't forget 25.5 points a game, 2.5 blocks, 12.7 rebounds, 3.7 rebounds, 80 percent from the line, and 50 percent from the field. Timmy played with the Admiral so he knows how to handle being a Twin Tower.
C
Pau Gasol gets the start at Center. The scruffy Spaniard shot 56.7 % from the field in 2008-9, was 3rd team All NBA, won a ring, and averaged 18.3 points, 9.4 rebounds, and 3.7 assists. He played with Andrew Bynum so he's used to being part of a Twin Towers set up and playing with the Kobster he knows when to defer to the alpha dogs. Complains about paella at Cheesecake Factory.

Back Up PGs
Mookie Blaylock, the 1994-95 edition, All Star, 1st Team Defense, 2.5 steals per game, 7.7 assists, 17.2 points. Defensive pest, hardly a let down when GP's on the bench.

Baron Davis, 2003-4. Instant offense, always brings the neck beard. 3rd Team NBA, All Star, 22.9 pts, 7.9 assists, and 2.4 steals a game.  Makes funny internet videos.

Backup SG

Hersey Hawkins-The 1996-7 edition is here to shoot the 3 at 40.3% percent clip, bring it defensively, and be rock solid come the playoffs (1997 playoffs shot 47% overall, 45.3% from 3, 91% from the line while averaging 15.3 pts, 4.5 boards, and 2.8 assists. Great alliteration.

Brent Barry, combo guard 2001-2 Brent Barry is a year removed from leading the league in 3 pt percentage and still managed to hit 3's at 42% clip while averaging 14.4 pts, 5.4 rebs, and 5.3 assists. Not a jerk like his Dad.

Dell Curry, 1998-9 shooting specialist. Steph's dad is on call to shoot three pointers which he did that year at 47.6%.

Backup SFs
Cedric Ceballos 1995-6, score the rock. CC shot 53% from the field and pulled in 6.0 rebounds a game. He's in to run and gun and dunk blind folded.
Derrick McKey 1994-5, defense. 2nd Team All Defense. Derrick can also hit the open shot at 49% or 36% from 3.

Back Up Bigs

Antoine Walker 01-02, Dance Captain-scoring, rebounds. May start depending on match up. 22.2 pts, 8, rebounds, and 5 assists.
Rasheed Wallace 04-05-offense, defense, intensity. RW only averaged 14.5 pts, 8.2 rebs, and 1.8 blocks on a balanced Pistons title team. He'll bring the same balance and big shot making for the Sixers.
Elden Campbell 96-97-big body, nice touch, 6 fouls. Last man off the bench. The Lakers scoring leader for 1990-9, Elden's mostly here to defense Shaq and the other larger centers. Has similar numbers to RW in the year chosen.
NJ Nyets.
A.Iguodala,Nene,A. Brooks, H. Warrick, ,C.Delfino,MoWilliams,Nick Collison,Reggie Williams, T. Douglas, E. Barron,Q. Ross,James Anderson, Jeff Pendergraph

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #267 on: May 27, 2010, 08:50:03 PM »

Online Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 53006
  • Tommy Points: 2571
76ers in Review aka Fo, Fo, Fo
The overall goal of my team was to pick the most efficient seasons for my players making an offensive and defensive Juggernaut.I tried to pick years when my players sacrificed for the common good and were the most efficient (see PP, Gasol, and Rasheed).  Depending on the matchup, the Sixers may start either Wallace or Walker to give the front court more outside offense. Mckey, Hawkins, and Blaylock are first 3 subs then the bigs.The Sixers will run when able especially with the second unit. Elden Campbell will play more minutes when Wallace and Walker get ejected.

Coach Poppovich always get the most out of his crew and is pumped to have more weapons to complement Tim "Title" Duncan. Considering Popp managed Stephen Jackson successfully he and tri-captains GP, TD, and PP should manage the more volatile players (Walker, Wallace, and GP).

PG
Gary Payton, the Glove, will be my starting point guard. In the 1997-8 season not only was he 1st Team NBA and 1st Team Defense, he averaged 17.2 pts, 8.3 ast, 4.6 rebs, and 2.3 steals a game. GP will hit the 3, find the open man, and lock down the opposing team's point guard.
SG
Brandon Roy, gets the nod at starting shooting guard. In the 2008-9 season, this All Star and 3rd Team All NBA was the 7th most efficient player in the NBA, was top 3 in offensive win shares, and averaged 22.6 points, 5.1 assists, 4.7 rebounds, while shooting 47 percent from the field, 37.7 percent from 3 point land, and 82.4 percent from the line.
SF
Paul Pierce, the Captain and the Truth, gets the start at small forward. The cagey veteran played perhaps the best basketball of his life in 2007-8, and since adjusting to the New Big 3 was so easy, he should be able to join the star studded Sixers as well. This 2nd Team All NBA and Finals MVP is the perfect complementary player, rising to the occasion of the big game while averaging 20.6 points a game, 5.1 rebounds, and 4.7 assists. Got a title drought? Give him the right team mates and he'll solve it.
PF
Tim "Title Town" Duncan is the starting PF. You might remember his coming out party in 2001-2. League MVP, All Star, 1st Team ALL NBA and Defensive. Oh yeah and don't forget 25.5 points a game, 2.5 blocks, 12.7 rebounds, 3.7 rebounds, 80 percent from the line, and 50 percent from the field. Timmy played with the Admiral so he knows how to handle being a Twin Tower.
C
Pau Gasol gets the start at Center. The scruffy Spaniard shot 56.7 % from the field in 2008-9, was 3rd team All NBA, won a ring, and averaged 18.3 points, 9.4 rebounds, and 3.7 assists. He played with Andrew Bynum so he's used to being part of a Twin Towers set up and playing with the Kobster he knows when to defer to the alpha dogs. Complains about paella at Cheesecake Factory.

Back Up PGs
Mookie Blaylock, the 1994-95 edition, All Star, 1st Team Defense, 2.5 steals per game, 7.7 assists, 17.2 points. Defensive pest, hardly a let down when GP's on the bench.

Baron Davis, 2003-4. Instant offense, always brings the neck beard. 3rd Team NBA, All Star, 22.9 pts, 7.9 assists, and 2.4 steals a game.  Makes funny internet videos.

Backup SG

Hersey Hawkins-The 1996-7 edition is here to shoot the 3 at 40.3% percent clip, bring it defensively, and be rock solid come the playoffs (1997 playoffs shot 47% overall, 45.3% from 3, 91% from the line while averaging 15.3 pts, 4.5 boards, and 2.8 assists. Great alliteration.

Brent Barry, combo guard 2001-2 Brent Barry is a year removed from leading the league in 3 pt percentage and still managed to hit 3's at 42% clip while averaging 14.4 pts, 5.4 rebs, and 5.3 assists. Not a jerk like his Dad.

Dell Curry, 1998-9 shooting specialist. Steph's dad is on call to shoot three pointers which he did that year at 47.6%.

Backup SFs
Cedric Ceballos 1995-6, score the rock. CC shot 53% from the field and pulled in 6.0 rebounds a game. He's in to run and gun and dunk blind folded.
Derrick McKey 1994-5, defense. 2nd Team All Defense. Derrick can also hit the open shot at 49% or 36% from 3.

Back Up Bigs

Antoine Walker 01-02, Dance Captain-scoring, rebounds. May start depending on match up. 22.2 pts, 8, rebounds, and 5 assists.
Rasheed Wallace 04-05-offense, defense, intensity. RW only averaged 14.5 pts, 8.2 rebs, and 1.8 blocks on a balanced Pistons title team. He'll bring the same balance and big shot making for the Sixers.
Elden Campbell 96-97-big body, nice touch, 6 fouls. Last man off the bench. The Lakers scoring leader for 1990-9, Elden's mostly here to defense Shaq and the other larger centers. Has similar numbers to RW in the year chosen.


I would like to see your team use a three man big man rotation with Rasheed Wallace starting at power forward, Duncan at center and Pau Gasol as your first choice and only backup big man. I would only turn to Campbell or Antoine if one of those players couldn't go.

Rasheed Wallace is one of the best glue guys in this league. A top of the line defender who was a lockdown defender against all three frontcourt positions and capable of switching onto both guard positions. His post game, size and athleticism, and shooting ability pose a large variety of matchup problems for the opposition and are a great complement to Duncan's post up game.

Pau Gasol is a fantastic main big man off the bench because he can shoulder a team's offense and take advantage of the talent drop off from the opponent's starters to bench players. In this role, Pau Gasol gives you a matchup advantage against Boston + Chicago + Indiana + NJ + possibly Milwaukee. Gasol's quickness, length and overall offensive ability are a huge problem for other teams to contain.

That three man big man rotation is one of the best strengths on your team. Playing a fourth big puts a less talented player in the mix and reduces your advantage against other teams. The Sixers will be much better off with a short big man rotation that maximizes their playing time.

--------------------------------------

The backup wing is a problem area for the Sixers. I would again go with a short rotation and use only one wing (Ceballos). Hawkins is undersized and will be a defensive liability against many of the opponent wing players and Brent Barry is outclassed as a rotation player at this level. A nice utility player (10th-12th man) who can provide cover for all three perimeter positions but he shouldn't crack a team's rotation (Barry).

Hersey Hawkins should not have been selected at all in this game, he is a liability at this level of competition. Well, he could be a useful solid third string PG for some teams but not here because Baron + Mookie are both better than him at the position. He has very little value and should be at the end of your roster.

I would use Baron Davis ahead of Mookie Blaylock. I would also avoid using one of his later Hornets year as the year selected because his shot selection was horrific during those seasons. Lowers his value.

I would either use Baron's second season with the Hornets when he was more of a pure point guard (only 11 shot attempts per game versus 19 later on) and led the Hornets on a impressive postseason run with his strong defense + his incredible playmaking in transition ... or use one of his top seasons with the Warriors when he was a better go-to guy than his later Hornets seasons.

---------------------------------------------------

The Sixers are a tremendously strong ball club. One of the best teams in this competition.
« Last Edit: May 27, 2010, 08:56:24 PM by Who »

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #268 on: May 27, 2010, 09:52:06 PM »

Offline RebusRankin

  • Satch Sanders
  • *********
  • Posts: 9143
  • Tommy Points: 923
Fake San Antonio Spurs.

PG - Tim Hardaway (1992/93)
SG - Kobe Bryant (2002/2003)
SF - Ron Artest (2003/2004)
PF - Chris Webber (2000/2001)
C - Dikembe Mutombo (1994/95)

Bench
Derek Harper (1989/90)
Nick Van Exel (2000/2001)
Michael Finley (1999/2000)
Steve Smith (2001/2002)
Detlef Schrempf (1994/95)
Ron Harper (1996/97)
Elton Brand (2005/2006)
Terry Cummings (1989/90)
Buck Williams (1989/90)
Rony Seikaly (1992/93)

Yes, we’re built around Kobe, which likely hurts me. However here it goes.

Starters

Kobe will be the centerpiece our team is built around. He averaged 30ppg that year along with over 5 apg and 6rpg. This is the young athletic Kobe. He’ll be our primary scorer on offense and also a lockdown defender on the wing.

Webber will play a role similar to Pau Gasol on the current Lakers. He’ll be the number two option on offense, mixing a post game with a solid outside jump shot.

Hardaway will run the offense. His first role will be to set up the rest of the team (he averaged over 10 appg that year) but also will provide scoring.

Artest’s role will be that of lock-down, all league defender.

Deke’s job will be to rebound and defend. He was the DPOY the year I chose.

Bench

Finley is our first wing off the bench. He’ll swing between the SG and SF spots. We feel he’ll provide an all around game (scoring, playmaking, rebounding and defense).

Elton Brand will swing between PF and C as the first big off the bench. We feel he gives us a low post scorer, rebounder and shot blocker.

Buck Williams will play both PF and C off the bench. Similar to Deke but with more offense, his primary role will be to defend and rebound.

Schrempf will play SF, PF and C depending on the match-ups. He provides scoring, rebound and outside shooting. We plan to use him also as a mismatch creator.

Derek Harper provides scoring, playmaking and defense. He was an all-nba defender the year we chose.

We chose the year we did for Steve Smith because he shot almost 48% from 3 that year. His role is designated shooter off the bench.

We chose the year we did for Harper because he teamed with Jordan and Pippen that year to provide stifling perimeter D. He’s role is defender off the bench, especially against bigger pgs.

Terry Cummings gives us another big man who can score, rebound and defend.

Seikaley is our third center but will be used in certain match-ups where we need more offense from the 5 spot.

Van Exel is our insurance pg.

Our team was designed with defense and specific roles in mind.

Re: CB Historical Draft - Team Rosters/Panelists Comments
« Reply #269 on: May 28, 2010, 09:37:17 AM »

Offline stoyko

  • Jrue Holiday
  • Posts: 399
  • Tommy Points: 77

Who thanks for the great feedback. I agree with your assessment of my bigs. I went back and forth on who to pair Duncan with and can just as easily go with Wallace and bring Gasol off the bench in super sub role (think Walton in 86). Walker will play limited minutes as the 4th Big off the bench.

Back up wings are a weakness but I'm confident that Ceballos and McKey will be solid at the 3. Back up shooting guard is where the Sixers are weakest but I can live with Hawkins and Barry for the 10-15 minutes a game when Roy isn't playing. Hawkins was a great complementary player on the Payton and Kemp  sonics.

For PG, I prefer Blaylock defense but will defer to Davis based on the matchup and need for scoring.

Thanks again for your thoughtful analysis.
NJ Nyets.
A.Iguodala,Nene,A. Brooks, H. Warrick, ,C.Delfino,MoWilliams,Nick Collison,Reggie Williams, T. Douglas, E. Barron,Q. Ross,James Anderson, Jeff Pendergraph