1. In total rebounds per game the C's are 29th
In total rebound percentage the C's are tied for 25th
That makes them an overall bad rebounding team any way you look at it. You just can't discount offensive rebounding. Among the top ten offensive rebounding teams in the league in number per game and/or offensive rebounding percentage are: the Lakers, Hawks, Bucks, Thunder, Trailblazers and Suns. All are playoff bound teams.
3. There's a very large difference between having a bad shooting night every once in a while that is severely off the norm and being the Jekyl/Hyde inconsistent shooters the Celtics have been collectively as a team this year. I think it's a valid criticism given their nearly 5 percentage point drop in three point percentage this year.
4. Nate won us some games? That's news to me. Say what you want about his potential to be a bench scorer but the reality is he's averaging just 6.5 PPG for the Celtics or less PPG than Eddie House was scoring, a player who no one would ever confuse for a major scoring threat of the bench.
Regarding PosImpos' supposed what have you done for me lately look at Nate, well I think you need to follow your own advice. Over the last 13 games Nate has averaged scoring just 4.9 PPg with 4 of those games being held scoreless and only one being a double digit scoring night.
Nate has potential to be a bench scorer but that is far from reality at this point.
5. and 6. Paul has played more to his potential lately but overall, none of the Big Three are playing like superstars anymore and Rondo too easily has nights like last night to be considered a superstar yet.
1. I don't think you can lump defensive and offensive rebounding into the same statistic. It's a completely different ballgame and requires different basketball tools.
For instance, Shelden Williams increases our amount of OReb%, but has really hurt our Dreb% in his time out there on the court. You can blame that on Sheed, but Baby has also been paired with him.
Also doesn't help that Garnett hasn't been top form or close to it(where he's at now) for most of the season.
The teams I consider to be true contenders (LAL, Orlando, Denver, Cleveland, Boston, Utah, Dallas, Atl) and their offensive rebounding % ratings: 6th, 10th, 13th, 18th, 21st, 25th, 26th, 28th. I just can't consider something essential when the top 3 reads Memphis, Detroit, OKC.
4. I consider Nate to have put some games out of reach as part of the second unit and that has helped us to win some games. 10 point leads disintegrating were the norm and that has happened a lot less since Nate came aboard and Pierce and KG have roared back from their January form.
Look at the Charlotte game as an example. Nate comes in with a 4 point lead against the best defensive team in the league and his play turns that into a 15 point lead and provides the cushion for the starters and he carried the offense all by himself. The Pacers game was a similar story. Nate's 3's absolutely triggered that blowout.