Should I make this trade? (football)

[Shoot the J]

I am one of the many to lose Owen Daniels, number 1 TE in most leagues this year. I have been offered PHI TE Brent Celek for my Percy Harvin. Take a look at my team and help me please! I need to decide before the end of today and i keep going back and forth. League is a PPR, 6pt per TD, 1pt per 15yds rushing & receiving.

QB - Aaron Rodgers (GB)
WR - Brandon Marshall (DEN)
WR - Anquan Boldin (ARI)
RB - Adrian Peterson (MIN)
RB - Rashard Mendenhall (PIT)
TE - Fred Davis (WAS)
K - Lawrence Tynes (NYG)
DEF - ATL
BN - Shonne Greene (NYJ)
BN - LaDanian Tomlinson (SD)
BN - Anthony Gonzalez (IND)
BN - Nate Burleson (SEA)
BN - Hakeem Nicks (NYG)
BN - Percy Harvin (MIN)
BN - Chester Taylor (MIN)

Any suggestions?

[Donoghus]

If Harvin is constantly riding your bench (which it seems in this case), it may not be a bad idea to take the trade.  You would be upgrading your TE position.  Davis isn't going to get you much at all on a weekly basis.

Another thing you might want to consider is packaging some of that talent on your bench and trying to upgrade.   Try and see if you can get a big talent at one of the key positions.

[Roy Hobbs]

I'd make it.  Harvin is a good player, but you have other guys to start in his place.

[RebusRankin]

Would you trade Steve Smith (NY) and Pierre Thomas for Jones-Drew?

[Shoot the J]

i asked you first.

Tough call. JAX is awful, but MJD is as good as they come. Depending on the depth of your team, i would make that trade

[Donoghus]

Would you trade Steve Smith (NY) and Pierre Thomas for Jones-Drew?

What's the rest of your team look like?  How many WRs do you start?  How many RBs do you start?  Is there a flex position?

Basically, need more info.

[Shoot the J]

Thanks for the help guys

[RebusRankin]

Would you trade Steve Smith (NY) and Pierre Thomas for Jones-Drew?

What's the rest of your team look like?  How many WRs do you start?  How many RBs do you start?  Is there a flex position?

Basically, need more info.

I have Rice, Forte and Thomas at running back.
Steve Smith, Moss, White, Breaston and Berrien at WR
Schaub and McNabb at QB

We start 2 rb and 3 wr.

[Shoot the J]

Assuming the "Moss" is Randy and not Santana, I would make this trade.

[Donoghus]

Would you trade Steve Smith (NY) and Pierre Thomas for Jones-Drew?

What's the rest of your team look like?  How many WRs do you start?  How many RBs do you start?  Is there a flex position?

Basically, need more info.

I have Rice, Forte and Thomas at running back.
Steve Smith, Moss, White, Breaston and Berrien at WR
Schaub and McNabb at QB

We start 2 rb and 3 wr.

Hmmm...its a tough one.

I'd be more inclined to pass because, albeit you're upgrading at RB, you're going thin at the WR position.  In my eyes, the upgrade at RB is more than offset by your loss at WR. 

[xmuscularghandix]

sgdf