Giddens could have been a sleeper. You never know. I wouldn't necessarily compare him to Kedrick Brown, who simply lacked the intelligence to understand the game at the NBA level.
As for Hudson, he's learned the offense and plays with his head up. He's made the right passes and taken the right shots. He has progressed since Summer league.
Let me add that I'd like to see the Celtics use Hudson the way the Pistons used Lindsay Hunter: to play disruptive defense against the other team's backup pg and pick up full court. Even if you don't get steals, you can make the other team waste time getting into its offense.
Honestly, I can't blame Danny for the Giddens pick. He was an absolute stud coming into college, and after making some questionable decisions, which extended his college career a bit (and turned many scouts off to him), he had a very impressive Senior year.
And let's face it, he has all the tools to be a very good NBA player. He is long, athletic, plays with a ton of energy, is a passable shooter, ball-handler, a very good defender, and a great rebounder. But unfortunately, he is also a spaz.
So I can see Danny saying "you know what, if he could just learn to control his emotions, and play within a system, he could be the steal of the draft". When you have the last pick in the first round, that is the kind of risk you take.
I also don't blame him for passing up on Chalmers, since they were still high on Pruitt at the time, who has a very similar skillset (he just also is a deer in headlights), and CDR just is an awkward player.
Obviously the pick was a mistake, but I think there was some logic behind it in a sort of "we might as well swing for the fences with this pick" sort of way.
Oh yeah, and for all of the Red Flags there were for Giddens, there were even more for Deandre Jordan, who looked like the second coming of Chris Taft and POB combined. And despite his gaudy numbers in meaningless games, I am still not sure Jordan will be any better pro than Giddens.
Finally, I am predicting right now that Giddens will hang around this league, and will eventually make himself a decent amount of money as an exciting, energetic player on a bad team.