Poll: Bring Back Toine or Gerald?

[ThaPreacher]

Can I also mandate that the loser of this poll is hereby strictly forbidden from being topic of any future "Bring Back..." threads?

and what the hell, the winner too? 

Agreed, As soon as we stop paying Scalabrine's salary. Heh!

[The Walker Wiggle]

Would choosing between Walker and Green be made easier if we tag-teamed them with another Celtic "legend" in a best 2 out of 3 falls, Bunkhouse Stampede match?

My vote would be Walker and Todd Day vs. Green and Milt Palacios.

I'd kill to see 'Toine and his big gut in jeans, cowboy boots and a flannel a la Dusty Rhodes climbing in to the ring!

[dang]it Bento Box, I almost gave you a Tommy Point for that.

[Edgar]

nice run keep this going people



p.s. we are discussing a top 30 C of all time with Gerald Green?
really?

Come on give him love...

[Prof. Clutch]

This is like asking me to choose which fingernail I want ripped off my body.

If we're doing this in a joking sense I would have to say Antoine because I freakin' loved watching the guy when he was here.  He was incredibly entertaining and passionate and gave fans something to talk about even when we sucked.  In a joking way, it would be really funny to see him trying to contribute and break through on this team which would have absolutely no room for him.

If you are asking us to seriously consider this I have to go with Green.  He can't offer us anything and wouldn't be able to help us, but I guess if no logic applied to the situation you would have to choose a young player who has at least some athletic qualities over an old player who wouldn't be able to crack the rotation.

Since its you Redz, I'll choose that you're joking:  Employee #8 it is.

Oh, and I choose my left pinky fingernail.

[Roy Hobbs]

Antoine, baby.  If I have to choose between two non-contributors, I'm taking the guy who helped left the Celts back to momentary respectability.

[Redz]

This is like asking me to choose which fingernail I want ripped off my body.

If we're doing this in a joking sense I would have to say Antoine because I freakin' loved watching the guy when he was here.  He was incredibly entertaining and passionate and gave fans something to talk about even when we sucked.  In a joking way, it would be really funny to see him trying to contribute and break through on this team which would have absolutely no room for him.

If you are asking us to seriously consider this I have to go with Green.  He can't offer us anything and wouldn't be able to help us, but I guess if no logic applied to the situation you would have to choose a young player who has at least some athletic qualities over an old player who wouldn't be able to crack the rotation.

Since its you Redz, I'll choose that you're joking:  Employee #8 it is.

Oh, and I choose my left pinky fingernail.

Take it as you choose, but your answer will be binding when judgment day comes...not sure what that means, but I'm sticking with it...So who'd you vote for?

[Mr October]

Toine for 3!!!

[Prof. Clutch]

This is like asking me to choose which fingernail I want ripped off my body.

If we're doing this in a joking sense I would have to say Antoine because I freakin' loved watching the guy when he was here.  He was incredibly entertaining and passionate and gave fans something to talk about even when we sucked.  In a joking way, it would be really funny to see him trying to contribute and break through on this team which would have absolutely no room for him.

If you are asking us to seriously consider this I have to go with Green.  He can't offer us anything and wouldn't be able to help us, but I guess if no logic applied to the situation you would have to choose a young player who has at least some athletic qualities over an old player who wouldn't be able to crack the rotation.

Since its you Redz, I'll choose that you're joking:  Employee #8 it is.

Oh, and I choose my left pinky fingernail.

Take it as you choose, but your answer will be binding when judgment day comes...not sure what that means, but I'm sticking with it...So who'd you vote for?

Well judgement day could be having to watch the two of them play a never ending game of one on one.

I'm went with my man Walker and all the sexyness that comes with him:

[2short]

 
why can't we choose
neither
scal can outplay antoine
tony allen would kill gerald
hmmm, think about it

[amenhotep04]

As an assistant coach?  Definitely Toine.

As dance coach?  Toine.

Evaluator of hamburger quality? Toine.

Player?  None of the above.

[Redz]

This is like asking me to choose which fingernail I want ripped off my body.

If we're doing this in a joking sense I would have to say Antoine because I freakin' loved watching the guy when he was here.  He was incredibly entertaining and passionate and gave fans something to talk about even when we sucked.  In a joking way, it would be really funny to see him trying to contribute and break through on this team which would have absolutely no room for him.

If you are asking us to seriously consider this I have to go with Green.  He can't offer us anything and wouldn't be able to help us, but I guess if no logic applied to the situation you would have to choose a young player who has at least some athletic qualities over an old player who wouldn't be able to crack the rotation.

Since its you Redz, I'll choose that you're joking:  Employee #8 it is.

Oh, and I choose my left pinky fingernail.

Take it as you choose, but your answer will be binding when judgment day comes...not sure what that means, but I'm sticking with it...So who'd you vote for?

Well judgement day could be having to watch the two of them play a never ending game of one on one.

I'm went with my man Walker and all the sexyness that comes with him:

I saw that image earlier and managed to not use it...Thanks for taking one for the team with that one 

[Mr October]

Ahhh!!!!! My eyes!!!!!!

[BrickJames]

I'm actually shocked that the poll results are even at this point, 22/22.

But then again, this is a CBlog thread about Antoine and Gerald, so it is not to be taken seriously, I suppose.

[Redz]

Quite the comeback (no pun intended) by Toine!  He was way down with day crowd.

[Redz]

I'm actually shocked that the poll results are even at this point, 22/22.

But then again, this is a CBlog thread about Antoine and Gerald, so it is not to be taken seriously, I suppose.

It does go a long way towards explaining why their names are pretty much alternated in the "bring back" threads though.