You absolutely right. The same thing happened with Rasheed. People kept talking about how they wanted Dice more (which I bashed), and didn't want Sheed in green, and as soon as he signed he's the most popular guy in town. There is a reason Hill is Danny's number one choice. HE FITS IN PERFECTLY. Does that mean he is the perfect or the best player? No, that means that he's a very, VERY intelligent player on both ends of the floor that still has the scoring, D, versatility, and athletisism to push this team over the edge and make them better.
With that being said, I've heard his wife loves NY, which is tough to overcome. However, I was also speaking with Bill Guerin (just won a Stanley Cup with the Penguins) and he and his wife were talking about their move from Long Island to Pitt. She mentioned that she didn't like the city as much as living out on LI, but that you can't pass up a chance to play with guys like Crosby and Malkin, or pass up a chance to play for a cup again. Hopefully Hill's wife is just as grounded as Mrs. Guerin.