I like Julian Wright, but he's a little bit of a project and I wonder how much he'd help next year. I don't like MoPete.
I'd rather offer Turnover Tony and Scal for Nocioni, frankly.
I like some parts of Noc's game but he's a bit of a gunner for my liking. He has a propensity to taking running one handers in traffic and I more than have my fill of those with Rondo on the court.
I think this may be an issue of perception.
Nocioni06-07: 46.7 FG%, 38.3 3PT%, .536 eFG%, .578 TS%
07-08: 43.2 FG%, 36.4 3PT%, .504 eFG%, .549 TS%
08-09: 42.7 FG%, 39.9 3PT%, .515 eFG%, .555 TS%
Mo Pete06-07: 42.9 FG%, 35.9 3PT%, .532 eFG%, .555 TS%
07-08: 41.7 FG%, 39.4 3PT%, .526 eFG%. .549 TS%
08-09: 39.9 FG%, 38.8 3PT%, .489 eFG%, .499 TS%
Over the past three seasons, Nocioni has shot a higher percentage from the floor than Peterson, and he's been better from three in two of those three seasons. He's also generally been a more efficient player. When you couple that with his versatility (Nocioni can play the 4), his younger age, and his superior health, I think Nocioni is the better choice.
The only advantage Peterson has is his contract (2 years, $12.4 million vs. 3 years, $21 million). I like Wright, but not enough to make up the difference between the two players in my mind.