Wow there's a lot of Howard hate in this thread. I read one post that said he isn't really muscular-- kiiinda gotta question that-- and another that said his game was all athleticism and size-- that's true, but that doesn't make him any less of a beast. For example, Its not like shaq had or has the greatest finesse game of all time. He just sets up on the left block and rams you until he can either dunk over you, spin around you and dunk, or take a hook-like shot that goes in 20% of the time. Yet he's one of the most dominant centers of all time. I don't find the hating on Howard for being too athletic and not skilled enough to be justified-- an alley oop and a running hook both get you two points.
And for the record, I loved the Superman dunk. The contest is all about the showmanship, not the technicalities. So he didn't touch the rim. Maybe its not by all standards a dunk, but it had all the components that make a dunk exciting. It had a great leap, a fun gimmick/trick, and it was a LOUD finish. It was a remarkable shot, too, if you think about. He gunned it through the hoop like a baseball player from above the rim. Good enough for a 10 in my book.