Rate Our Players on a Scale of one to a hundred

[KG Living Legend]

Example

KG-95
PP-93
RA-91
RR-84
KP-73
LP-75
Baby-63
House-69
T Allen-65
Scal-45
Patty O-25
Pruitt-59

Any major objections???

[Scottie]

I think you are being very generous with your marking, but you have to factor in the bias so it all comes down to personal opinion.

I disagree with House though, I would have him as 68.

[Roy Hobbs]

Powe isn't better than Perk.

[KG Living Legend]

Good call Roy, wanted to see if anyone caught that.

What do you think Perk is a 78 or 79. And Powe is a 75?

Also to the other poster you disagree that House is not a 69 but a 68. Wow. What a fierce objection.

[Scottie]

Good call Roy, wanted to see if anyone caught that.

What do you think Perk is a 78 or 79. And Powe is a 75?

Also to the other poster you disagree that House is not a 69 but a 68. Wow. What a fierce objection.

Just being a wiseguy to illustrate my point . Everyone will have their own scores and it's hard to argue your own opinion against someone else's on a subjec that is so subjective.

[Slugger]

PP 90 - whatever 90 means, but i'll go along
KG 90
RA 80
KP 80
RR 75
TA 60
LP 60
BS 50
GD 50
EH 50
GP 40
POB 10

[xmuscularghandix]

PP 92 (97 in fourth quarter)
KG 91 (96 when ha goes berzerker on defense)
RA 89
RR 81
KP 78

TA 71
LP 74
EH 69
GD 69
GP 70
BS 67
POB60
SC 69

[housecall]

how can you rate POB without seeing him play any serious minutes yet?...i gave him a 100 until i can see what really tells me different.

[CoachBo]

PP 95
KG 90
RA 90
KP 65
RR 65
TA 25
LP 50
BS 30
GD 40
EH 50
GP 25
POB 2

[ACF]

Also to the other poster you disagree that House is not a 69 but a 68. Wow. What a fierce objection.

He's a 68.6 in my book.



Isn't a 100 scale a bit much
to work with? Why not 50?

[crownsy]

Example

KG-95
PP-93
RA-91
RR-84
KP-73
LP-75
Baby-63
House-69
T Allen-65
Scal-45
Patty O-25
Pruitt-59

Any major objections???

those top 4 are thier nba2k9 ratings. dead serious.

[wdleehi]

KG 95
Pierce 94
Allen 89
Rondo 85
Perkins 80
Powe 75
House 65
TA 65
Scali 65
Davis 35
Pruitt 65
POB 0
Cassell I

[wdleehi]

KG 95
Pierce 94
Allen 89
Rondo 85
Perkins 80
Powe 75
House 65
TA 65
Scali 65
Davis 35
Pruitt 65
POB 0
Cassell I

I think I might have been to easy to the bench.

[CoachBo]

Hahahaha.

Even I gave Paddy a 2. I may have overrated him.

[cordialb]

I'm pretty sure your use of the word 'ARE' instead of 'OUR' just gave me a migraine.