Forum Rankings/Players

[Roy Hobbs]

I added Doc, between the bench and the starters.

[celticmaestro]

I'm for 'Toine's inclusion.

I think when you get to 1000 it should be a change of player every 500 posts rather than 1000, I'll be Ainge for a long time otherwise

[nickagneta]

I added Doc, between the bench and the starters.

Quite the turnaround in one year, huh Roy? Last year at this time you weren't exactly the biggest Doc supporter on this site and now he is a Celtic for life for winning a title as a coach.

Good move. Doc earned it.

[Roy Hobbs]

I added Doc, between the bench and the starters.

Quite the turnaround in one year, huh Roy? Last year at this time you weren't exactly the biggest Doc supporter on this site and now he is a Celtic for life for winning a title as a coach.

Good move. Doc earned it.

Well...  I'm still not sold on Doc as a great in-game coach.  In fact, I think he's pretty poor in terms of a lot of areas of execution (calling timeouts, rotations).  However, the man got results, and he certainly has a bigger impact on winning and losing than, say, J.R. Giddens.

Don't delude yourself on this "Celtic for life" stuff, though.  There's a reason he's listed below the starters, rather than next to Danny.

Switching gears, but if I redid the list after his retirement, I'm pretty sure Pierce would go at the 17 stars level.  I think that's fitting.

[nickagneta]

I added Doc, between the bench and the starters.

Quite the turnaround in one year, huh Roy? Last year at this time you weren't exactly the biggest Doc supporter on this site and now he is a Celtic for life for winning a title as a coach.

Good move. Doc earned it.

Well...  I'm still not sold on Doc as a great in-game coach.  In fact, I think he's pretty poor in terms of a lot of areas of execution (calling timeouts, rotations).  However, the man got results, and he certainly has a bigger impact on winning and losing than, say, J.R. Giddens.

Don't delude yourself on this "Celtic for life" stuff, though.  There's a reason he's listed below the starters, rather than next to Danny.

Switching gears, but if I redid the list after his retirement, I'm pretty sure Pierce would go at the 17 stars level.  I think that's fitting.

Actually, I think he already deserves to be there but I understand that the active players will always be towards the beginning.

BTW, I threw that "for life" part in for giggles. I knew I would hear back from you on that.

Of course, if the Celtics go back to back maybe some more consideration might be put in to moving him further down the list??

[Edgar]

I love the 8 post Antoine Walker idea. 

[Redz]

I love the 8 post Antoine Walker idea. 

But what about Big Al

[Edgar]

I love the 8 post Antoine Walker idea. 

But what about Big Al

put Big Toine.

[BballTim]

 According to those numbers, I'm in the top 30 all time for posts. That's scary, both for me and the people who have to read my posts...

  Now, back to your discussion.

[Roy Hobbs]

 According to those numbers, I'm in the top 30 all time for posts. That's scary, both for me and the people who have to read my posts...

  Now, back to your discussion.

What's scary for me is that I have as many posts as the #4, #5, and #7 posters, combined.

[indeedproceed]

Yeah....but not the 4,5 and 6 huh, Roy? No sir. the number six poster is IMPORTANT.

[Roy Hobbs]

Yeah....but not the 4,5 and 6 huh, Roy? No sir. the number six poster is IMPORTANT.

Haha.  There was a time when I was higher than 3, 4, and 5, I think.  You guys are catching up.

[nickagneta]

Roy has more Tommy Points than all but 45 other posters have posts.

[celticmaestro]

Why am I seeing stars on people with 150 posts?

[Redz]

Why am I seeing stars on people with 150 posts?

Any head trauma of late? (seeing stars...get it? hardy-har-har....yup, well...ok....I'm off for trick-or-treating nayhem with the wee ones...i think I'll egg some teenagers)